| #1 | A+ | Bluffsview Elementary School | Columbus | Worthington City | 82% | 77% | Exceeds Expectations | 432 |
| #2 | A+ | Stevenson Elementary | Columbus | Grandview Heights Schools | 80% | 79% | Meets Expectations | 367 |
| #3 | A+ | Clinton Elementary School | Columbus | Columbus City Schools District | 77% | 47% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 460 |
| #4 | A+ | Worthington Hills Elementary School | Columbus | Worthington City | 77% | 76% | Meets Expectations | 532 |
| #5 | A+ | Granby Elementary School | Columbus | Worthington City | 72% | 69% | Exceeds Expectations | 431 |
| #6 | A- | Indian Springs Elementary School | Columbus | Columbus City Schools District | 60% | 36% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 363 |
| #7 | A- | Brookside Elementary School | Columbus | Worthington City | 58% | 56% | Exceeds Expectations | 339 |
| #8 | A- | Hamilton Elementary School | Columbus | Hamilton Local | 58% | 55% | Exceeds Expectations | 952 |
| #9 | A- | Hilliard Horizon Elementary School | Columbus | Hilliard City | 58% | 53% | Exceeds Expectations | 555 |
| #10 | A- | Hamilton Intermediate School | Columbus | Hamilton Local | 57% | 55% | Exceeds Expectations | 679 |
| #11 | B+ | Daniel Wright Elementary School | Columbus | Dublin City | 54% | 49% | Exceeds Expectations | 584 |
| #12 | B+ | Hawthorne Elementary School | Columbus | Westerville City | 54% | 40% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 543 |
| #13 | B+ | Indianola Informal K 8 School | Columbus | Columbus City Schools District | 52% | 35% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 684 |
| #14 | B | Winterset Elementary School | Columbus | Columbus City Schools District | 50% | 34% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 298 |
| #15 | B | Ecole Kenwood French Immersion | Columbus | Columbus City Schools District | 48% | 43% | Exceeds Expectations | 452 |
| #16 | B- | Alpine Elementary School | Columbus | Columbus City Schools District | 43% | 20% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 307 |
| #17 | B- | Sedalia Elementary | Columbus | Groveport Madison Local | 43% | 36% | Exceeds Expectations | 616 |
| #18 | C+ | Cranbrook Elementary School | Columbus | Columbus City Schools District | 38% | 30% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 266 |
| #19 | C+ | Prairie Norton Elementary School | Columbus | South-Western City | 38% | 33% | Exceeds Expectations | 504 |
| #20 | C+ | Cesar Chavez College Preparatory School (Charter) | Columbus | Cesar Chavez College Preparatory School | 37% | 12% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 318 |
| #21 | C | Westgate Alternative Elementary School | Columbus | Columbus City Schools District | 35% | 32% | Exceeds Expectations | 277 |
| #22 | C | Georgian Heights Alt Elementary School | Columbus | Columbus City Schools District | 34% | 32% | Exceeds Expectations | 463 |
| #23 | C | Columbus Spanish Immersion K 7 School | Columbus | Columbus City Schools District | 33% | 21% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 456 |
| #24 | C | United Preparatory Academy (Charter) | Columbus | United Preparatory Academy | 33% | 15% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 268 |
| #25 | C | Gables Elementary School | Columbus | Columbus City Schools District | 32% | 39% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 428 |
| #26 | C | Horizon Science Academy Elementary School (Charter) | Columbus | Horizon Science Academy Elementary School | 32% | 14% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 396 |
| #27 | C | Northgate Intermediate | Columbus | Columbus City Schools District | 32% | 24% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 267 |
| #28 | C | Olde Orchard Alt Elementary School | Columbus | Columbus City Schools District | 32% | 30% | Exceeds Expectations | 481 |
| #29 | C | Berwick Alternative K 8 School | Columbus | Columbus City Schools District | 31% | 16% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 633 |
| #30 | C | International Acad Of Columbus (Charter) | Columbus | International Acad Of Columbus | 30% | 16% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 306 |
| #31 | C | Stewart Alternative Elementary School | Columbus | Columbus City Schools District | 30% | 15% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 312 |
| #32 | C- | Avalon Elementary School | Columbus | Columbus City Schools District | 30% | 21% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 375 |
| #33 | C- | Focus Learning Academy Of Northern Columbus (Charter) | Columbus | Focus Learning Academy of Northern Columbus | 30% | 15% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 654 |
| #34 | C- | Franklin Woods Intermediate School | Columbus | South-Western City | 30% | 33% | Meets Expectations | 623 |
| #35 | C- | South Scioto Academy (Charter) | Columbus | South Scioto Academy | 30% | 12% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 202 |
| #36 | C- | West Franklin Elementary School | Columbus | South-Western City | 30% | 28% | Exceeds Expectations | 476 |
| #37 | C- | South Columbus Preparatory Academy At Southfield (Charter) | Columbus | South Columbus Preparatory Academy at Southfield | 29% | 17% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 277 |
| #38 | C- | Columbus Humanities Arts And Technology Academy (Charter) | Columbus | Columbus Humanities Arts and Technology Academy | 28% | 20% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 630 |
| #39 | C- | Noble Academy Columbus (Charter) | Columbus | Noble Academy-Columbus | 28% | 36% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 285 |
| #40 | C- | Colerain Elementary School | Columbus | Columbus City Schools District | 27% | 29% | Meets Expectations | 169 |
| #41 | C- | Asbury Elementary School | Columbus | Groveport Madison Local | 26% | 26% | Meets Expectations | 485 |
| #42 | C- | South Columbus Preparatory Academy At German Village (Charter) | Columbus | South Columbus Preparatory Academy at German Village | 25% | 17% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 266 |
| #43 | D+ | Finland Elementary School | Columbus | South-Western City | 25% | 26% | Meets Expectations | 355 |
| #44 | D+ | Madison Elementary School | Columbus | Groveport Madison Local | 25% | 26% | Meets Expectations | 348 |
| #45 | D+ | Parkmoor Elementary School | Columbus | Columbus City Schools District | 25% | 14% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 284 |
| #46 | D+ | Prairie Lincoln Elementary School | Columbus | South-Western City | 25% | 31% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 529 |
| #47 | D+ | Northland Preparatory And Fitness Academy (Charter) | Columbus | Northland Preparatory and Fitness Academy | 23% | 12% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 196 |
| #48 | D+ | Oakmont Elementary School | Columbus | Columbus City Schools District | 23% | 20% | Exceeds Expectations | 280 |
| #49 | D+ | Binns Elementary School | Columbus | Columbus City Schools District | 22% | 32% | Underperforms Expectations | 297 |
| #50 | D+ | Columbus Performance Academy (Charter) | Columbus | Columbus Performance Academy | 22% | 13% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 176 |
| #51 | D+ | Columbus Preparatory And Fitness Academy (Charter) | Columbus | Columbus Preparatory and Fitness Academy | 22% | 16% | Exceeds Expectations | 380 |
| #52 | D+ | Performance Academy Eastland (Charter) | Columbus | Performance Academy Eastland | 22% | 12% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 277 |
| #53 | D+ | South Mifflin Stem Academy K 6 | Columbus | Columbus City Schools District | 22% | 14% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 243 |
| #54 | D | Educational Academy For Boys And Girls (Charter) | Columbus | Educational Academy for Boys & Girls | 20% | 15% | Exceeds Expectations | 143 |
| #55 | D | Hubbard Elementary School | Columbus | Columbus City Schools District | 20% | 22% | Meets Expectations | 243 |
| #56 | D | Salem Elementary School | Columbus | Columbus City Schools District | 20% | 20% | Meets Expectations | 303 |
| #57 | D | Stiles Elementary School | Columbus | South-Western City | 20% | 19% | Meets Expectations | 612 |
| #58 | D | Valley Forge Elementary School | Columbus | Columbus City Schools District | 20% | 19% | Meets Expectations | 240 |
| #59 | D | Westside Academy (Charter) | Columbus | Westside Academy | 20% | 12% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 311 |
| #60 | D | Cedarwood Alternative Elementary School | Columbus | Columbus City Schools District | 18% | 30% | Underperforms Expectations | 335 |
| #61 | D | East Franklin Elementary School | Columbus | South-Western City | 18% | 33% | Underperforms Expectations | 242 |
| #62 | D | Great Western Academy (Charter) | Columbus | Great Western Academy | 18% | 21% | Meets Expectations | 667 |
| #63 | D | Cassady Alternative Elementary School | Columbus | Columbus City Schools District | 17% | 16% | Meets Expectations | 305 |
| #64 | D | Graham Elementary And Middle School (Charter) | Columbus | Graham Elementary and Middle School | 17% | 20% | Meets Expectations | 331 |
| #65 | D | Kids Care Elementary (Charter) | Columbus | Kids Care Elementary | 17% | 14% | Exceeds Expectations | 129 |
| #66 | D | Oakland Park Alternative Elementary | Columbus | Columbus City Schools District | 17% | 21% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 279 |
| #67 | D | Whitehall Preparatory And Fitness Academy (Charter) | Columbus | Whitehall Preparatory and Fitness Academy | 17% | 12% | Exceeds Expectations | 323 |
| #68 | D | Devonshire Alternative Elementary School | Columbus | Columbus City Schools District | 16% | 21% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 440 |
| #69 | D- | Liberty Elementary School | Columbus | Columbus City Schools District | 15% | 15% | Meets Expectations | 504 |
| #70 | D- | Scottwood Elementary School | Columbus | Columbus City Schools District | 15% | 17% | Meets Expectations | 449 |
| #71 | D- | Shady Lane Elementary School | Columbus | Columbus City Schools District | 15% | 15% | Meets Expectations | 330 |
| #72 | D- | West Mound Elementary School | Columbus | Columbus City Schools District | 15% | 28% | Underperforms Expectations | 323 |
| #73 | D- | Avondale Elementary School | Columbus | Columbus City Schools District | 14% | 28% | Underperforms Expectations | 240 |
| #74 | D- | Capital Collegiate Preparatory Academy (Charter) | Columbus | Capital Collegiate Preparatory Academy | 14% | 13% | Meets Expectations | 134 |
| #75 | D- | Columbus Africentric Early College ES | Columbus | Columbus City Schools District | 14% | 15% | Meets Expectations | 418 |
| #76 | D- | Zenith Academy East (Charter) | Columbus | Zenith Academy East | 14% | 13% | Meets Expectations | 310 |
| #77 | D- | Forest Park Elementary School | Columbus | Columbus City Schools District | 13% | 23% | Underperforms Expectations | 380 |
| #78 | D- | Woodcrest Elementary School | Columbus | Columbus City Schools District | 13% | 14% | Meets Expectations | 262 |
| #79 | D- | Duxberry Park Alternative Elementary School | Columbus | Columbus City Schools District | 12% | 14% | Meets Expectations | 194 |
| #80 | D- | Lindbergh Elementary School | Columbus | Columbus City Schools District | 12% | 25% | Underperforms Expectations | 227 |
| #81 | D- | Maize Road Elementary School | Columbus | Columbus City Schools District | 12% | 20% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 310 |
| #82 | D- | Parsons Elementary School | Columbus | Columbus City Schools District | 12% | 18% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 354 |
| #83 | D- | Siebert Elementary School | Columbus | Columbus City Schools District | 12% | 18% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 314 |
| #84 | D- | Sullivant Avenue Community School (Charter) | Columbus | Sullivant Avenue Community School | 12% | 17% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 277 |
| #85 | D- | Valleyview Elementary School | Columbus | Columbus City Schools District | 12% | 16% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 286 |
| #86 | D- | Zenith Academy West (Charter) | Columbus | Zenith Academy West | 12% | 18% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 142 |
| #87 | D- | Columbus Bilingual Academy North (Charter) | Columbus | Columbus Bilingual Academy-North | 11% | 14% | Meets Expectations | 475 |
| #88 | D- | Dunloe Elementary School | Columbus | Groveport Madison Local | 11% | 20% | Underperforms Expectations | 491 |
| #89 | D- | East Columbus Elementary School | Columbus | Columbus City Schools District | 11% | 14% | Meets Expectations | 367 |
| #90 | D- | Huyag Bell Elementary School | Columbus | Columbus City Schools District | 11% | 21% | Underperforms Expectations | 415 |
| #91 | D- | Millennium Community School (Charter) | Columbus | Ohio Achievement Charter Schools Inc. dba Millennium Commun | 11% | 15% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 383 |
| #92 | D- | North Columbus Preparatory Academy (Charter) | Columbus | North Columbus Preparatory Academy | 11% | 13% | Meets Expectations | 159 |
| #93 | D- | West Broad Elementary School | Columbus | Columbus City Schools District | 11% | 24% | Underperforms Expectations | 369 |
| #94 | F | Broadleigh Elementary School | Columbus | Columbus City Schools District | 10% | 17% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 277 |
| #95 | F | Eastgate Elementary School | Columbus | Columbus City Schools District | 10% | 14% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 207 |
| #96 | F | Imagine Columbus Primary School (Charter) | Columbus | Imagine Columbus Primary Academy | 10% | 20% | Underperforms Expectations | 206 |
| #97 | F | Lincoln Park Elementary School | Columbus | Columbus City Schools District | 10% | 23% | Underperforms Expectations | 251 |
| #98 | F | North Linden Elementary School | Columbus | Columbus City Schools District | 10% | 21% | Underperforms Expectations | 313 |
| #99 | F | Southwood Elementary School | Columbus | Columbus City Schools District | 10% | 25% | Underperforms Expectations | 273 |
| #100 | F | Central Point Preparatory Academy (Charter) | Columbus | Central Point Preparatory Academy | 9% | 17% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 229 |
| #101 | F | East Linden Elementary School | Columbus | Columbus City Schools District | 9% | 13% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 283 |
| #102 | F | Easthaven Elementary School | Columbus | Columbus City Schools District | 9% | 11% | Meets Expectations | 395 |
| #103 | F | Fairmoor Elementary School | Columbus | Columbus City Schools District | 9% | 13% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 359 |
| #104 | F | Fairwood Alternative Elementary School | Columbus | Columbus City Schools District | 9% | 12% | Meets Expectations | 237 |
| #105 | F | Leawood Elementary School | Columbus | Columbus City Schools District | 9% | 15% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 313 |
| #106 | F | Northtowne Elementary School | Columbus | Columbus City Schools District | 9% | 19% | Underperforms Expectations | 304 |
| #107 | F | Como Elementary School | Columbus | Columbus City Schools District | 8% | 17% | Underperforms Expectations | 234 |
| #108 | F | Highland Elementary School | Columbus | Columbus City Schools District | 8% | 17% | Underperforms Expectations | 301 |
| #109 | F | Linden Stem Academy K 6 | Columbus | Columbus City Schools District | 8% | 12% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 369 |
| #110 | F | Livingston Elementary School | Columbus | Columbus City Schools District | 8% | 13% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 326 |
| #111 | F | Starling Pk 8 | Columbus | Columbus City Schools District | 8% | 31% | Underperforms Expectations | 557 |
| #112 | F | Sullivant Elementary School | Columbus | Columbus City Schools District | 8% | 12% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 257 |
| #113 | F | Watkins Elementary School | Columbus | Columbus City Schools District | 8% | 13% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 295 |
| #114 | F | Weinland Park Elementary School | Columbus | Columbus City Schools District | 8% | 14% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 320 |
| #115 | F | Burroughs Elementary School | Columbus | Columbus City Schools District | 7% | 20% | Underperforms Expectations | 388 |
| #116 | F | Innis Elementary School | Columbus | Columbus City Schools District | 7% | 19% | Underperforms Expectations | 224 |
| #117 | F | Eakin Elementary School | Columbus | Columbus City Schools District | 6% | 9% | Meets Expectations | 263 |
| #118 | F | Hamilton Stem Academy K 6 | Columbus | Columbus City Schools District | 6% | 14% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 385 |
| #119 | F | Moler Elementary School | Columbus | Columbus City Schools District | 6% | 13% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 303 |
| #120 | F | The Bessie Sherrod Price Preparatory Academy (Charter) | Columbus | Renaissance Academy dba Bessie Sherrod Price Preparatory Aca | 6% | 13% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 100 |
| #121 | F | Trevitt Elementary School | Columbus | Columbus City Schools District | 6% | 11% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 201 |
| #122 | F | East Bridge Academy Of Excellence (Charter) | Columbus | East Bridge Academy of Excellence | 5% | 14% | Underperforms Expectations | 121 |
| #123 | F | Ohio Avenue Elementary School | Columbus | Columbus City Schools District | 5% | 17% | Underperforms Expectations | 241 |
| #124 | F | Windsor Stem Academy K 6 | Columbus | Columbus City Schools District | 5% | 15% | Underperforms Expectations | 329 |