| #1 | A+ | Glenwood School | Short Hills | Millburn Township School District | 94% | 71% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 378 |
| #2 | A+ | Cornelia F Bradford School | Jersey City | Jersey City Public Schools | 89% | 72% | Exceeds Expectations | 962 |
| #3 | A+ | Milton Avenue School | Chatham | School District of the Chathams | 89% | 55% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 282 |
| #4 | A+ | Princeton Charter School (Charter) | Princeton | Princeton Charter School | 89% | 60% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 424 |
| #5 | A+ | Meadowbrook | Hillsdale | Hillsdale School District | 87% | 44% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 332 |
| #6 | A+ | Point Road School | Little Silver | Little Silver Boro School District | 87% | 58% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 370 |
| #7 | A+ | Betsy Ross Elementary | Mahwah | Mahwah Township Public School District | 86% | 46% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 276 |
| #8 | A+ | Hilldale School | Pine Brook | Montville Township School District | 86% | 59% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 320 |
| #9 | A+ | School 28 | Paterson | Paterson Public School District | 86% | 46% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 484 |
| #10 | A+ | Alexander Hamilton School | Glen Rock | Glen Rock Public School District | 85% | 57% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 281 |
| #11 | A+ | Hartshorn School | Short Hills | Millburn Township School District | 85% | 72% | Meets Expectations | 437 |
| #12 | A+ | Mount Prospect Elementary School | Basking Ridge | Bernards Township School District | 85% | 63% | Exceeds Expectations | 539 |
| #13 | A+ | Salt Brook School | New Providence | New Providence School District | 85% | 58% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 607 |
| #14 | A+ | Deane Porter Elementary School | Rumson | Rumson Borough School District | 84% | 63% | Exceeds Expectations | 384 |
| #15 | A+ | Deerfield School | Short Hills | Millburn Township School District | 84% | 75% | Meets Expectations | 402 |
| #16 | A+ | Radburn Elementary School | Fair Lawn | Fair Lawn Public School District | 84% | 52% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 393 |
| #17 | A+ | South Mountain School | Millburn | Millburn Township School District | 84% | 64% | Exceeds Expectations | 284 |
| #18 | A+ | Viola L Sickles School | Fair Haven | Fair Haven School District | 84% | 57% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 452 |
| #19 | A+ | Washington School | Millburn | Millburn Township School District | 84% | 66% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 388 |
| #20 | A+ | Wyoming School | Millburn | Millburn Township School District | 84% | 62% | Exceeds Expectations | 352 |
| #21 | A+ | Mendham Township Elementary School | Brookside | Mendham Township School District | 83% | 62% | Exceeds Expectations | 456 |
| #22 | A+ | Milltown Primary School | Bridgewater | Bridgewater-Raritan Regional School District | 83% | 60% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 362 |
| #23 | A+ | Central School | Haddonfield | Haddonfield School District | 82% | 53% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 437 |
| #24 | A+ | H W Mountz Elementary School | Spring Lake | Spring Lake Borough | 82% | 49% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 152 |
| #25 | A+ | Hatikvah International Academy Charter School (Charter) | East Brunswick | Hatikvah International Academy Charter School | 82% | 49% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 595 |
| #26 | A+ | Luther Lee Emerson School | Demarest | Demarest School District | 82% | 59% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 247 |
| #27 | A+ | Roosevelt Science Technology Engineering And Mathematics (st | Pennsauken | | 82% | 28% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 136 |
| #28 | A+ | Brookdale Avenue School | Verona | Verona Public School District | 81% | 46% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 123 |
| #29 | A+ | Franklin Elementary School | Summit | Summit Public School District | 81% | 60% | Exceeds Expectations | 327 |
| #30 | A+ | Harrison Elementary School | Livingston | Livingston Board of Education School District | 81% | 63% | Exceeds Expectations | 489 |
| #31 | A+ | Hillside Elementary School | Allendale | Allendale Public School District | 81% | 60% | Exceeds Expectations | 382 |
| #32 | A+ | Lyncrest Elementary School | Fair Lawn | Fair Lawn Public School District | 81% | 36% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 207 |
| #33 | A+ | Walter Stillman School | Tenafly | Tenafly Public School District | 81% | 61% | Exceeds Expectations | 347 |
| #34 | A+ | Wildwood Elementary School | Mountain Lakes | Mountain Lakes Public School District | 81% | 62% | Exceeds Expectations | 458 |
| #35 | A+ | Allen W Roberts School | New Providence | New Providence School District | 80% | 56% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 676 |
| #36 | A+ | Edward H Bryan | Cresskill | Cresskill Public School District | 80% | 54% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 531 |
| #37 | A+ | Hilltop School | Mendham | Mendham Borough School District | 80% | 52% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 262 |
| #38 | A+ | Hoboken Dual Language Charter School (Charter) | Hoboken | Hoboken Dual Language Charter School | 80% | 49% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 422 |
| #39 | A+ | Lincoln Hubbard Elementary School | Summit | Summit Public School District | 80% | 59% | Exceeds Expectations | 328 |
| #40 | A+ | Riverside School | Princeton | Princeton Public School District | 80% | 56% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 293 |
| #41 | A+ | School No 1 | Fort Lee | Fort Lee School District | 80% | 49% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 542 |
| #42 | A+ | Upper School | Englewood Cliffs | Englewood Cliffs School District | 80% | 62% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 264 |
| #43 | A+ | Hillside Elementary School | Livingston | Livingston Board of Education School District | 79% | 60% | Exceeds Expectations | 438 |
| #44 | A+ | Jvb Wicoff Elementary School | Plainsboro | West Windsor-Plainsboro Regional School District | 79% | 58% | Exceeds Expectations | 275 |
| #45 | A+ | Mary E Roberts Elementary School | Moorestown | Moorestown Township Public School District | 79% | 36% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 313 |
| #46 | A+ | Mount Pleasant Elementary School | Livingston | Livingston Board of Education School District | 79% | 64% | Meets Expectations | 443 |
| #47 | A+ | Orchard Elementary School | Ridgewood | Ridgewood Public School District | 79% | 51% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 346 |
| #48 | A+ | Stony Brook Elementary School | Pennington | Hopewell Valley Regional School District | 79% | 48% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 400 |
| #49 | A+ | Travell Elementary School | Ridgewood | Ridgewood Public School District | 79% | 56% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 346 |
| #50 | A+ | Alpine Elementary School | Alpine | Alpine Public School District | 78% | 58% | Exceeds Expectations | 165 |
| #51 | A+ | Catherine E Doyle Elementary School | Wood Ridge | Wood-Ridge School District | 78% | 41% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 435 |
| #52 | A+ | George Washington School | Mahwah | Mahwah Township Public School District | 78% | 45% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 193 |
| #53 | A+ | Gouldmountain Elementary School | N Caldwell | North Caldwell School District | 78% | 54% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 296 |
| #54 | A+ | Grandview Elementary School | N Caldwell | North Caldwell School District | 78% | 57% | Exceeds Expectations | 401 |
| #55 | A+ | Hillsborough Township Elementary School | Hillsborough | Hillsborough Township Public School District | 78% | 44% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 486 |
| #56 | A+ | Hillside Elementary School | Closter | Closter Public School District | 78% | 62% | Meets Expectations | 623 |
| #57 | A+ | Ho Ho Kus Public School | Ho Ho Kus | Ho-Ho-Kus School District | 78% | 62% | Meets Expectations | 542 |
| #58 | A+ | Monmouth Junction Elementary School | Monmouth Junction | South Brunswick School District | 78% | 59% | Exceeds Expectations | 279 |
| #59 | A+ | Oak Street School | Basking Ridge | Bernards Township School District | 78% | 56% | Exceeds Expectations | 413 |
| #60 | A+ | Oak Tree Elementary School | Monroe Township | Monroe Township School District | 78% | 52% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 644 |
| #61 | A+ | Parkway Elementary School | Paramus | Paramus Public School District | 78% | 46% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 300 |
| #62 | A+ | Ralph S Maugham School | Tenafly | Tenafly Public School District | 78% | 61% | Exceeds Expectations | 353 |
| #63 | A+ | Torey J Sabatini School | Madison | Madison Public School District | 78% | 42% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 309 |
| #64 | A+ | Wilson Elementary School | Westfield | Westfield Public School District | 78% | 53% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 345 |
| #65 | A+ | George C Baker Elementary School | Moorestown | Moorestown Township Public School District | 77% | 45% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 397 |
| #66 | A+ | Howard B Brunner Elementary School | Scotch Plains | Scotch Plains-Fanwood School District | 77% | 44% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 425 |
| #67 | A+ | J Ackerman Coles Elementary School | Scotch Plains | Scotch Plains-Fanwood School District | 77% | 51% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 535 |
| #68 | A+ | Memorial Elementary School | Montvale | Montvale Board of Education School District | 77% | 51% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 517 |
| #69 | A+ | North End Elementary School | Cedar Grove | Cedar Grove Township School District | 77% | 39% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 305 |
| #70 | A+ | Washington Elementary School | Summit | Summit Public School District | 77% | 49% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 310 |
| #71 | A+ | Cedar Hill School | Towaco | Montville Township School District | 76% | 49% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 328 |
| #72 | A+ | Essex Fells Elementary School | Essex Fells | Essex Fells School District | 76% | 60% | Meets Expectations | 244 |
| #73 | A+ | Frost Elementary School | East Brunswick | East Brunswick Township School District | 76% | 39% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 375 |
| #74 | A+ | J Fithian Tatem School | Haddonfield | Haddonfield School District | 76% | 49% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 432 |
| #75 | A+ | Liberty Corner School | Liberty Corner | Bernards Township School District | 76% | 55% | Exceeds Expectations | 447 |
| #76 | A+ | Marshall Elementary School | S Orange | South Orange-Maplewood School District | 76% | 43% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 475 |
| #77 | A+ | Riverbank Charter School Of Excellence (Charter) | Roebling | Riverbank Charter School of Excellence | 76% | 44% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 154 |
| #78 | A+ | Somerville Elementary School | Ridgewood | Ridgewood Public School District | 76% | 53% | Exceeds Expectations | 367 |
| #79 | A+ | South Valley Elementary School | Moorestown | Moorestown Township Public School District | 76% | 52% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 392 |
| #80 | A+ | Washington Elementary School | Westfield | Westfield Public School District | 76% | 51% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 263 |
| #81 | A+ | Woods Road Elementary School | Hillsborough | Hillsborough Township Public School District | 76% | 48% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 375 |
| #82 | A+ | Clara E Coleman School | Glen Rock | Glen Rock Public School District | 75% | 54% | Exceeds Expectations | 351 |
| #83 | A+ | Cranberry Pines Elementary | Medford | Medford Township School District | 75% | 46% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 358 |
| #84 | A+ | Elizabeth Haddon School | Haddonfield | Haddonfield School District | 75% | 49% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 376 |
| #85 | A+ | Henry B Milnes Elementary School | Fair Lawn | Fair Lawn Public School District | 75% | 45% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 428 |
| #86 | A+ | Irwin Elementary School | East Brunswick | East Brunswick Township School District | 75% | 36% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 321 |
| #87 | A+ | Joseph D Sharp Elementary School | Cherry Hill | Cherry Hill School District | 75% | 57% | Exceeds Expectations | 444 |
| #88 | A+ | Malcolm S Mackay School | Tenafly | Tenafly Public School District | 75% | 60% | Meets Expectations | 331 |
| #89 | A+ | Richard Byrd | Glen Rock | Glen Rock Public School District | 75% | 58% | Exceeds Expectations | 269 |
| #90 | A+ | Ridge Elementary School | Ridgewood | Ridgewood Public School District | 75% | 56% | Exceeds Expectations | 441 |
| #91 | A+ | Ridge Ranch Elementary School | Paramus | Paramus Public School District | 75% | 48% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 351 |
| #92 | A+ | Ridgewood Avenue School | Glen Ridge | Glen Ridge Public School District | 75% | 56% | Exceeds Expectations | 530 |
| #93 | A+ | Sea Girt Elementary School | Sea Girt | Sea Girt Borough School District | 75% | 52% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 132 |
| #94 | A+ | South End Elementary School | Cedar Grove | Cedar Grove Township School District | 75% | 42% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 354 |
| #95 | A+ | Thomas A Edison Elementary School | Westmont | Haddon Township School District | 75% | 36% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 140 |
| #96 | A+ | Union Township Elementary School | Hampton | Union Township School District | 75% | 49% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 206 |
| #97 | A+ | Cedar Hill School | Basking Ridge | Bernards Township School District | 74% | 61% | Meets Expectations | 520 |
| #98 | A+ | Central School | Glen Rock | Glen Rock Public School District | 74% | 46% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 339 |
| #99 | A+ | Collins Elementary School | Livingston | Livingston Board of Education School District | 74% | 59% | Meets Expectations | 461 |
| #100 | A+ | Edith A Bogert Elementary School | Upper Saddle River | Upper Saddle River School District | 74% | 50% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 374 |
| #101 | A+ | Lafayette Avenue School | Chatham | School District of the Chathams | 74% | 57% | Exceeds Expectations | 545 |
| #102 | A+ | Lester C Noecker Roseland | Roseland | Roseland School District | 74% | 45% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 466 |
| #103 | A+ | Maurice Hawk Elementary School | West Windsor | West Windsor-Plainsboro Regional School District | 74% | 62% | Meets Expectations | 758 |
| #104 | A+ | Sara M Gilmore Academy | Union City | Union City School District | 74% | 25% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 390 |
| #105 | A+ | Warren Point Elementary School | Fair Lawn | Fair Lawn Public School District | 74% | 39% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 392 |
| #106 | A+ | Montgomery Lower Middle School | Skillman | Montgomery Township School District | 73% | 58% | Exceeds Expectations | 738 |
| #107 | A+ | Deerfield Elementary School | Mountainside | Mountainside School District | 70% | 50% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 467 |
| #108 | A+ | Indian Hill School | Holmdel | Holmdel Township School District | 69% | 50% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 657 |
| #109 | A | Bowne Munro Elementary School | East Brunswick | East Brunswick Township School District | 74% | 30% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 176 |
| #110 | A | Jefferson Elementary School | Westfield | Westfield Public School District | 74% | 55% | Exceeds Expectations | 466 |
| #111 | A | Littlebrook School | Princeton | Princeton Public School District | 74% | 60% | Meets Expectations | 387 |
| #112 | A | William J Mcginn Elementary School | Scotch Plains | Scotch Plains-Fanwood School District | 74% | 47% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 527 |
| #113 | A | Burnet Hill Elementary School | Livingston | Livingston Board of Education School District | 73% | 58% | Meets Expectations | 462 |
| #114 | A | Calvin Coolidge Elementary School | Wyckoff | Wyckoff Township Public School District | 73% | 52% | Exceeds Expectations | 315 |
| #115 | A | Elysian Charter School Of Hoboken (Charter) | Hoboken | Elysian Charter School | 73% | 49% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 292 |
| #116 | A | Haworth Public School | Haworth | Haworth Public School District | 73% | 60% | Meets Expectations | 424 |
| #117 | A | James Madison Intermediate School | Edison | Edison Township School District | 73% | 57% | Meets Expectations | 606 |
| #118 | A | Midland Elementary School | Paramus | Paramus Public School District | 73% | 45% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 189 |
| #119 | A | Oradell Public School | Oradell | Oradell Public School District | 73% | 59% | Meets Expectations | 804 |
| #120 | A | Roosevelt School | River Edge | River Edge School District | 73% | 48% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 478 |
| #121 | A | Washington Avenue School | Chatham | School District of the Chathams | 73% | 50% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 296 |
| #122 | A | Wesley D Tisdale Elementary School | Ramsey | Ramsey School District | 73% | 42% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 322 |
| #123 | A | Westmoreland Elementary School | Fair Lawn | Fair Lawn Public School District | 73% | 45% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 393 |
| #124 | A | Zane North Elementary School | Collingswood | Collingswood Public School District | 73% | 34% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 164 |
| #125 | A | Ann Blanche Smith | Hillsdale | Hillsdale School District | 72% | 41% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 299 |
| #126 | A | Bradley Gardens Primary School | Bridgewater | Bridgewater-Raritan Regional School District | 72% | 47% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 255 |
| #127 | A | Crim Primary School | Bridgewater | Bridgewater-Raritan Regional School District | 72% | 51% | Exceeds Expectations | 391 |
| #128 | A | Franklin Elementary School | Westfield | Westfield Public School District | 72% | 55% | Exceeds Expectations | 532 |
| #129 | A | J Spencer Smith School | Tenafly | Tenafly Public School District | 72% | 65% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 347 |
| #130 | A | Memorial Elementary School | Paramus | Paramus Public School District | 72% | 49% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 297 |
| #131 | A | Riker Hill Elementary School | Livingston | Livingston Board of Education School District | 72% | 68% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 478 |
| #132 | A | School No 3 | Fort Lee | Fort Lee School District | 72% | 34% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 339 |
| #133 | A | Troy Hills Elementary School | Parsippany | Parsippany-Troy Hills Township School District | 72% | 44% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 296 |
| #134 | A | Wayside Elementary School | Ocean | Township of Ocean School District | 72% | 33% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 574 |
| #135 | A | West Ridge Elementary School | Park Ridge | Park Ridge School District | 72% | 44% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 340 |
| #136 | A | Woodbrook Elementary School | Edison | Edison Township School District | 72% | 60% | Meets Expectations | 940 |
| #137 | A | Bay Head Elementary | Bay Head | Bay Head Borough School District | 71% | 56% | Meets Expectations | 123 |
| #138 | A | Brayton Elementary School | Summit | Summit Public School District | 71% | 47% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 304 |
| #139 | A | Central Elementary School | Great Meadows | Great Meadows Regional School District | 71% | 31% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 296 |
| #140 | A | Central School | Warren | Warren Township School District | 71% | 46% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 308 |
| #141 | A | Cherry Hill School | River Edge | River Edge School District | 71% | 51% | Exceeds Expectations | 713 |
| #142 | A | Dorchester Elementary School | Woodcliff Lake | Woodcliff Lake School District | 71% | 52% | Exceeds Expectations | 476 |
| #143 | A | Hamilton Primary School | Basking Ridge | Bridgewater-Raritan Regional School District | 71% | 57% | Meets Expectations | 479 |
| #144 | A | Harding Township School | New Vernon | Harding Township School District | 71% | 54% | Meets Expectations | 285 |
| #145 | A | Joseph F Brandt Elementary School | Hoboken | Hoboken Public School District | 71% | 50% | Exceeds Expectations | 562 |
| #146 | A | Lakeview Elementary School | Denville | Denville Township K-8 School District | 71% | 45% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 674 |
| #147 | A | Manito Elementary School | Oakland | Oakland Public School District | 71% | 44% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 256 |
| #148 | A | Martin Luther King Elementary School | Edison | Edison Township School District | 71% | 58% | Meets Expectations | 638 |
| #149 | A | Mary A Hubbard Elementary School | Ramsey | Ramsey School District | 71% | 49% | Exceeds Expectations | 371 |
| #150 | A | Seaview Elementary School | Linwood | Linwood City School District | 71% | 35% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 445 |
| #151 | A | Stonybrook Elementary School | Kinnelon | Kinnelon School District | 71% | 47% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 412 |
| #152 | A | Tamaques Elementary School | Westfield | Westfield Public School District | 71% | 55% | Meets Expectations | 414 |
| #153 | A | Toll Gate Grammar School | Pennington | Hopewell Valley Regional School District | 71% | 44% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 310 |
| #154 | A | Triangle Elementary School | Hillsborough | Hillsborough Township Public School District | 71% | 43% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 371 |
| #155 | A | Village Elementary School | Skillman | Montgomery Township School District | 71% | 60% | Meets Expectations | 628 |
| #156 | A | Wanamassa Elementary School | Wanamassa | Township of Ocean School District | 71% | 39% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 322 |
| #157 | A | Willard Elementary School | Ridgewood | Ridgewood Public School District | 71% | 56% | Meets Expectations | 471 |
| #158 | A | Applegarth Elementary School | Monroe Twp | Monroe Township School District | 70% | 51% | Exceeds Expectations | 468 |
| #159 | A | Bear Tavern Elementary School | Titusville | Hopewell Valley Regional School District | 70% | 43% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 459 |
| #160 | A | Hawes Elementary School | Ridgewood | Ridgewood Public School District | 70% | 49% | Exceeds Expectations | 362 |
| #161 | A | Lafayette Mills School | Manalapan | Manalapan-Englishtown Regional School District | 70% | 49% | Exceeds Expectations | 445 |
| #162 | A | Lenape Meadows | Mahwah | Mahwah Township Public School District | 70% | 48% | Exceeds Expectations | 343 |
| #163 | A | Lincoln School | Rutherford | Rutherford School District | 70% | 44% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 516 |
| #164 | A | Littleton Elementary School | Morris Plains | Parsippany-Troy Hills Township School District | 70% | 53% | Exceeds Expectations | 411 |
| #165 | A | Menlo Park Elementary School | Edison | Edison Township School District | 70% | 57% | Meets Expectations | 825 |
| #166 | A | Monmouth Beach Elementary School | Monmouth Beach | Monmouth Beach School District | 70% | 52% | Exceeds Expectations | 257 |
| #167 | A | Mount Tabor Elementary School | Mount Tabor | Parsippany-Troy Hills Township School District | 70% | 43% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 371 |
| #168 | A | Soaring Heights Charter School (Charter) | Jersey City | Soaring Heights Charter School | 70% | 27% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 270 |
| #169 | A | The Gray Charter School (Charter) | Newark | Gray Charter School | 70% | 11% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 344 |
| #170 | A | Thomas P Hughes School | Berkeley Hts | Berkeley Heights School District | 70% | 51% | Exceeds Expectations | 276 |
| #171 | A | Three Bridges School | Three Bridges | Readington Township School District | 70% | 39% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 303 |
| #172 | A | Tuscan Elementary School | Maplewood | South Orange-Maplewood School District | 70% | 42% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 577 |
| #173 | A | Valley View School | Montville Township | Montville Township School District | 70% | 51% | Exceeds Expectations | 365 |
| #174 | A | Village School | Holmdel | Holmdel Township School District | 70% | 52% | Exceeds Expectations | 803 |
| #175 | A | Wandell School | Saddle River | Saddle River School District | 70% | 57% | Meets Expectations | 107 |
| #176 | A | Warnsdorfer Elementary School | East Brunswick | East Brunswick Township School District | 70% | 47% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 361 |
| #177 | A | Woodside Avenue School | Franklin Lakes | Franklin Lakes School District | 70% | 43% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 272 |
| #178 | A | Brookside Place School | Cranford | Cranford Public School District | 69% | 49% | Exceeds Expectations | 355 |
| #179 | A | Gregory Elementary School | W Orange | West Orange Public Schools | 69% | 36% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 442 |
| #180 | A | John F Kennedy Elementary School | Wayne | Wayne Township Public School District | 69% | 38% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 377 |
| #181 | A | Northvail Elementary School | Parsippany | Parsippany-Troy Hills Township School District | 69% | 56% | Meets Expectations | 369 |
| #182 | A | Oak View Elementary School | Bloomfield | Bloomfield Township School District | 69% | 39% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 335 |
| #183 | A | Southern Boulevard School | Chatham | School District of the Chathams | 69% | 57% | Meets Expectations | 373 |
| #184 | A | Van Holten Primary School | Bridgewater | Bridgewater-Raritan Regional School District | 69% | 48% | Exceeds Expectations | 314 |
| #185 | A | Village Elementary School | West Windsor | West Windsor-Plainsboro Regional School District | 69% | 65% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 638 |
| #186 | A | Wemrock Brook School | Manalapan | Manalapan-Englishtown Regional School District | 69% | 55% | Meets Expectations | 596 |
| #187 | A | Woodfern Elementary School | Hillsborough | Hillsborough Township Public School District | 69% | 47% | Exceeds Expectations | 333 |
| #188 | A | Brookdale Elementary School | Bloomfield | Bloomfield Township School District | 68% | 40% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 316 |
| #189 | A | Campbell Elementary School | Metuchen | Metuchen Public School District | 68% | 47% | Exceeds Expectations | 689 |
| #190 | A | Cranbury School | Cranbury | Cranbury Township School District | 68% | 57% | Meets Expectations | 447 |
| #191 | A | High Mountain Road School | Franklin Lakes | Franklin Lakes School District | 68% | 53% | Meets Expectations | 300 |
| #192 | A | Holland Brook School | Whitehouse Station | Readington Township School District | 68% | 38% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 306 |
| #193 | A | Mckinley Elementary School | Westfield | Westfield Public School District | 68% | 45% | Exceeds Expectations | 332 |
| #194 | A | Mountview Road School | Morris Plains | Hanover Township School District | 68% | 42% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 248 |
| #195 | A | Navesink Elementary School | Atlantic Highlands | Middletown Township Public School District | 68% | 36% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 208 |
| #196 | A | Orange Avenue School | Cranford | Cranford Public School District | 68% | 46% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 765 |
| #197 | A | Peter Cooper School | Ringwood | Ringwood School District | 68% | 31% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 243 |
| #198 | A | River Plaza Elementary School | Red Bank | Middletown Township Public School District | 68% | 37% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 254 |
| #199 | A | Roberge Elementary School | River Vale | River Vale Public School District | 68% | 52% | Meets Expectations | 316 |
| #200 | A | Robertsville Elementary School | Morganville | Marlboro Township School District | 68% | 46% | Exceeds Expectations | 461 |
| #201 | A | School No 2 | Fort Lee | Fort Lee School District | 68% | 36% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 357 |
| #202 | A | Sunnymead Elementary School | Hillsborough | Hillsborough Township Public School District | 68% | 37% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 496 |
| #203 | A | Theunis Dey Elementary School | Wayne | Wayne Township Public School District | 68% | 47% | Exceeds Expectations | 435 |
| #204 | A | Center Grove School | Randolph | Randolph Township School District | 67% | 58% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 533 |
| #205 | A | Central Avenue School | Madison | Madison Public School District | 67% | 42% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 509 |
| #206 | A | Central Elementary School | East Brunswick | East Brunswick Township School District | 67% | 41% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 355 |
| #207 | A | Euclid Elementary School | Hasbrouck Heights | Hasbrouck Heights School District | 67% | 35% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 381 |
| #208 | A | Jessie F George Elementary | Township Of Washington | Westwood Regional School District | 67% | 43% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 275 |
| #209 | A | Mt Horeb School | Warren | Warren Township School District | 67% | 49% | Exceeds Expectations | 248 |
| #210 | A | Woodmont School | Pine Brook | Montville Township School District | 67% | 50% | Exceeds Expectations | 310 |
| #211 | A | Moorestown Upper Elementary School | Moorestown | Moorestown Township Public School District | 65% | 48% | Exceeds Expectations | 853 |
| #212 | A | Terence C Reilly School No 7 | Elizabeth | Elizabeth Public Schools | 64% | 34% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 1,126 |
| #213 | A | Morris Plains Borough School | Morris Plains | Morris Plains School District | 63% | 40% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 376 |
| #214 | A | Pierrepont School | Rutherford | Rutherford School District | 63% | 41% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 561 |
| #215 | A | Wood Ridge Intermediate School | Wood Ridge | Wood-Ridge School District | 63% | 34% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 244 |
| #216 | A- | Berkeley Elementary | Westwood | Westwood Regional School District | 67% | 41% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 274 |
| #217 | A- | Dogwood Hill Elementary School | Oakland | Oakland Public School District | 67% | 31% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 241 |
| #218 | A- | Hillview School | Pompton Plains | Pequannock Township School District | 67% | 37% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 304 |
| #219 | A- | Asher Holmes Elementary School | Morganville | Marlboro Township School District | 66% | 54% | Meets Expectations | 447 |
| #220 | A- | Bradford Elementary School | Upper Montclair | Montclair Public School District | 66% | 46% | Exceeds Expectations | 385 |
| #221 | A- | Chairville Elementary School | Medford | Medford Township School District | 66% | 43% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 397 |
| #222 | A- | Clark Mills School | Manalapan | Manalapan-Englishtown Regional School District | 66% | 46% | Exceeds Expectations | 477 |
| #223 | A- | Harrington Park School | Harrington Park | Harrington Park School District | 66% | 60% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 615 |
| #224 | A- | John A Forrest Elementary School | Fair Lawn | Fair Lawn Public School District | 66% | 38% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 269 |
| #225 | A- | Kirbys Mill Elementary School | Medford | Medford Township School District | 66% | 43% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 365 |
| #226 | A- | Lincoln Park Elementary School | Lincoln Park | Lincoln Park School District | 66% | 29% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 517 |
| #227 | A- | Merritt Memorial | Cresskill | Cresskill Public School District | 66% | 47% | Exceeds Expectations | 276 |
| #228 | A- | Mount Pleasant Elementary School | West Orange | West Orange Public Schools | 66% | 27% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 349 |
| #229 | A- | Sharon School | Robbinsville | Robbinsville Public School District | 66% | 53% | Meets Expectations | 1,005 |
| #230 | A- | T Baldwin Demarest Elementary School | Old Tappan | Old Tappan Public School District | 66% | 57% | Meets Expectations | 373 |
| #231 | A- | Albert Payson Terhune Elementary | Wayne | Wayne Township Public School District | 65% | 47% | Exceeds Expectations | 373 |
| #232 | A- | Anna C Scott Elementary School | Leonia | Leonia Public School District | 65% | 46% | Exceeds Expectations | 608 |
| #233 | A- | Avon Elementary School | Avon | Avon Boro School District | 65% | 46% | Exceeds Expectations | 117 |
| #234 | A- | Bayberry School | Watchung | Watchung Borough School District | 65% | 45% | Exceeds Expectations | 410 |
| #235 | A- | Bedminster Township Public School | Bedminster | Bedminster Township Public School District | 65% | 40% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 452 |
| #236 | A- | Dutch Neck Elementary School | West Windsor | West Windsor-Plainsboro Regional School District | 65% | 63% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 674 |
| #237 | A- | Forest Avenue School | Verona | Verona Public School District | 65% | 50% | Meets Expectations | 215 |
| #238 | A- | Highland Elementary School | Midland Park | Midland Park School District | 65% | 39% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 281 |
| #239 | A- | Hillside Elementary School | Montclair | Montclair Public School District | 65% | 50% | Meets Expectations | 541 |
| #240 | A- | Hopewell Elementary School | Hopewell | Hopewell Valley Regional School District | 65% | 48% | Exceeds Expectations | 414 |
| #241 | A- | Irene E Feldkirchner Elementary School | Green Brook | Green Brook Township Public School District | 65% | 43% | Exceeds Expectations | 381 |
| #242 | A- | Johnson Park School | Princeton | Princeton Public School District | 65% | 52% | Meets Expectations | 409 |
| #243 | A- | Jotham W Wakeman School | Jersey City | Jersey City Public Schools | 65% | 31% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 598 |
| #244 | A- | Kresson School | Voorhees | Voorhees Township School District | 65% | 41% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 492 |
| #245 | A- | Packanack Elementary School | Wayne | Wayne Township Public School District | 65% | 42% | Exceeds Expectations | 406 |
| #246 | A- | Stony Lane Elementary School | Paramus | Paramus Public School District | 65% | 45% | Exceeds Expectations | 216 |
| #247 | A- | Yantacaw School | Nutley | Nutley Public School District | 65% | 46% | Exceeds Expectations | 506 |
| #248 | A- | Allenwood Elementary School | Wall | Wall Township Public School District | 64% | 44% | Exceeds Expectations | 409 |
| #249 | A- | Amsterdam Elementary School | Hillsborough | Hillsborough Township Public School District | 64% | 53% | Meets Expectations | 390 |
| #250 | A- | Angelo L Tomaso School | Warren | Warren Township School District | 64% | 50% | Meets Expectations | 264 |
| #251 | A- | Charles H Bullock School | Montclair | Montclair Public School District | 64% | 37% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 423 |
| #252 | A- | Crescent Elementary School | Waldwick | Waldwick School District | 64% | 36% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 333 |
| #253 | A- | Eastlake Elementary School | Parsippany | Parsippany-Troy Hills Township School District | 64% | 44% | Exceeds Expectations | 370 |
| #254 | A- | Frank Defino Central Elementary School | Marlboro | Marlboro Township School District | 64% | 52% | Meets Expectations | 526 |
| #255 | A- | James Fallon Elementary School | Wayne | Wayne Township Public School District | 64% | 44% | Exceeds Expectations | 373 |
| #256 | A- | Lake Parsippany Elementary School | Parsippany | Parsippany-Troy Hills Township School District | 64% | 37% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 301 |
| #257 | A- | Lincoln Elementary School | Bergenfield | Bergenfield Borough School District | 64% | 31% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 406 |
| #258 | A- | Livingston Avenue School | Cranford | Cranford Public School District | 64% | 39% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 253 |
| #259 | A- | Marlboro Elementary School | Marlboro | Marlboro Township School District | 64% | 54% | Meets Expectations | 493 |
| #260 | A- | Mountain Park School | Berkeley Hts | Berkeley Heights School District | 64% | 49% | Meets Expectations | 223 |
| #261 | A- | South Mountain Elementary School | S Orange | South Orange-Maplewood School District | 64% | 50% | Meets Expectations | 618 |
| #262 | A- | St Cloud Elementary School | W Orange | West Orange Public Schools | 64% | 38% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 435 |
| #263 | A- | Wolf Hill School | Oceanport | Oceanport School District | 64% | 45% | Exceeds Expectations | 295 |
| #264 | A- | Woodside Elementary School | River Vale | River Vale Public School District | 64% | 54% | Meets Expectations | 335 |
| #265 | A- | Betty Mcelmon Elementary School | West Long Branch | West Long Branch School District | 63% | 36% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 326 |
| #266 | A- | Bragg Elementary School | Chester | Chester Township School District | 63% | 45% | Exceeds Expectations | 318 |
| #267 | A- | Brooks Crossing Elementary School | Monmouth Junction | South Brunswick School District | 63% | 55% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 623 |
| #268 | A- | Cambridge Elementary School | Kendall Park | South Brunswick School District | 63% | 49% | Meets Expectations | 410 |
| #269 | A- | Delia Bolden Elementary School | Maplewood | South Orange-Maplewood School District | 63% | 46% | Exceeds Expectations | 448 |
| #270 | A- | Edward T Hamilton | Voorhees | Voorhees Township School District | 63% | 44% | Exceeds Expectations | 516 |
| #271 | A- | Harrison Township Elementary School | Mullica Hill | Harrison Township School District | 63% | 47% | Meets Expectations | 770 |
| #272 | A- | Jersey City Global Charter School (Charter) | Jersey City | | 63% | 49% | Meets Expectations | 416 |
| #273 | A- | John Y Dater Elementary School | Ramsey | Ramsey School District | 63% | 52% | Meets Expectations | 366 |
| #274 | A- | Lawrence Brook Elementary School | East Brunswick | East Brunswick Township School District | 63% | 34% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 357 |
| #275 | A- | Middle Road School | Hazlet | Hazlet Township Public School District | 63% | 34% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 271 |
| #276 | A- | Richard Stockton Elementary School | Cherry Hill | Cherry Hill School District | 63% | 46% | Exceeds Expectations | 353 |
| #277 | A- | Rockaway Valley School | Boonton Township | Boonton Township School District | 63% | 47% | Meets Expectations | 386 |
| #278 | A- | Round Valley | Lebanon | Clinton Township School District | 63% | 41% | Exceeds Expectations | 366 |
| #279 | A- | Stone Harbor Elementary School | Stone Harbor | Stone Harbor School District | 63% | 60% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 85 |
| #280 | A- | Van Sciver Elementary School | Haddonfield | Haddon Township School District | 63% | 32% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 335 |
| #281 | A- | Watchung Elementary School | Montclair | Montclair Public School District | 63% | 45% | Exceeds Expectations | 394 |
| #282 | A- | Wenonah Elementary School | Wenonah | Wenonah Boro School District | 63% | 43% | Exceeds Expectations | 166 |
| #283 | A- | Whiton Elementary School | Neshanic Station | Branchburg Township School District | 63% | 48% | Meets Expectations | 587 |
| #284 | A- | William H Ross Iii School | Margate | Margate City School District | 63% | 44% | Exceeds Expectations | 184 |
| #285 | A- | Woodland School | Warren | Warren Township School District | 63% | 40% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 268 |
| #286 | A- | Brooklake School | Florham Park | Florham Park School District | 62% | 45% | Exceeds Expectations | 331 |
| #287 | A- | East Amwell Township | Ringoes | East Amwell Township School District | 62% | 36% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 375 |
| #288 | A- | Florence M Burd | Newton | Andover Regional School District | 62% | 31% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 237 |
| #289 | A- | Intervale Elementary School | Boonton | Parsippany-Troy Hills Township School District | 62% | 40% | Exceeds Expectations | 266 |
| #290 | A- | Katharine D Malone Elementary School | Rockaway | Rockaway Township School District | 62% | 43% | Exceeds Expectations | 259 |
| #291 | A- | Kings Road School | Madison | Madison Public School District | 62% | 46% | Meets Expectations | 277 |
| #292 | A- | Knollwood Elementary School | Piscataway | Piscataway Township School District | 62% | 36% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 508 |
| #293 | A- | Laning Avenue School | Verona | Verona Public School District | 62% | 41% | Exceeds Expectations | 243 |
| #294 | A- | Lincoln Elementary School | Edison | Edison Township School District | 62% | 49% | Meets Expectations | 926 |
| #295 | A- | Millstone River School | Plainsboro | West Windsor-Plainsboro Regional School District | 62% | 61% | Underperforms Expectations | 831 |
| #296 | A- | Nut Swamp Elementary School | Middletown | Middletown Township Public School District | 62% | 48% | Meets Expectations | 510 |
| #297 | A- | Riverview Elementary School | Denville | Denville Township K-8 School District | 62% | 44% | Exceeds Expectations | 465 |
| #298 | A- | Rockaway Meadow Elementary School | Parsippany | Parsippany-Troy Hills Township School District | 62% | 35% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 248 |
| #299 | A- | Shrewsbury Borough Elementary School | Shrewsbury | Shrewsbury Borough School District | 62% | 48% | Meets Expectations | 462 |
| #300 | A- | Signal Hill School | Voorhees | Voorhees Township School District | 62% | 44% | Exceeds Expectations | 447 |
| #301 | A- | Spring Lake Heights Elementary School | Spring Lake Heights | Spring Lake Heights School District | 62% | 41% | Exceeds Expectations | 307 |
| #302 | A- | Stony Brook Elementary School | Rockaway | Rockaway Township School District | 62% | 34% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 391 |
| #303 | A- | Taunton Forge Elementary School | Medford | Medford Township School District | 62% | 40% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 289 |
| #304 | A- | Unity Charter School (Charter) | Morristown | Unity Charter School | 62% | 44% | Exceeds Expectations | 263 |
| #305 | A- | Auten Road Intermediate School | Hillsborough | Hillsborough Township Public School District | 61% | 45% | Exceeds Expectations | 1,203 |
| #306 | A- | Colonial Road School | Franklin Lakes | Franklin Lakes School District | 61% | 49% | Meets Expectations | 255 |
| #307 | A- | Community Park School | Princeton | Princeton Public School District | 61% | 48% | Meets Expectations | 286 |
| #308 | A- | Edgemont Elementary School | Montclair | Montclair Public School District | 61% | 39% | Exceeds Expectations | 266 |
| #309 | A- | Edward V Walton Primary School | Springfield | Springfield Public School District | 61% | 42% | Exceeds Expectations | 551 |
| #310 | A- | Frank J Dugan Elementary School | Marlboro | Marlboro Township School District | 61% | 53% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 649 |
| #311 | A- | Grant Elementary School | Dumont | Dumont Public School District | 61% | 37% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 472 |
| #312 | A- | Lincoln School | Pompton Lakes | Pompton Lakes School District | 61% | 32% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 389 |
| #313 | A- | Old Mill Elementary School | Sea Girt | Wall Township Public School District | 61% | 42% | Exceeds Expectations | 363 |
| #314 | A- | Pleasant Valley School | Mullica Hill | Harrison Township School District | 61% | 41% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 568 |
| #315 | A- | Redwood Elementary School | W Orange | West Orange Public Schools | 61% | 27% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 426 |
| #316 | A- | Salem Drive School | Whippany | Hanover Township School District | 61% | 41% | Exceeds Expectations | 231 |
| #317 | A- | School 3 | Cliffside Park | Cliffside Park School District | 61% | 17% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 372 |
| #318 | A- | Valley View School | Califon | Lebanon Township School District | 61% | 37% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 290 |
| #319 | A- | William F Halloran School No22 | Elizabeth | Elizabeth Public Schools | 61% | 32% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 1,089 |
| #320 | A- | Patrick M Villano School | Emerson | Emerson Public School District | 60% | 41% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 253 |
| #321 | A- | Hammarskjold Upper Elementary School | East Brunswick | East Brunswick Township School District | 57% | 42% | Exceeds Expectations | 1,314 |
| #322 | A- | Slocum Skewes School | Ridgefield | Ridgefield School District | 45% | 29% | Exceeds Expectations | 666 |
| #323 | B+ | Indian Mills Elementary School | Shamong | Shamong Township School District | 61% | 36% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 368 |
| #324 | B+ | Marion T Bedwell Elementary School | Bernardsville | Somerset Hills Regional School District | 61% | 40% | Exceeds Expectations | 453 |
| #325 | B+ | School No 4 | Fort Lee | Fort Lee School District | 61% | 45% | Meets Expectations | 400 |
| #326 | B+ | Strawbridge Elementary School | Westmont | Haddon Township School District | 61% | 37% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 236 |
| #327 | B+ | A Russell Knight Elementary School | Cherry Hill | Cherry Hill School District | 60% | 41% | Exceeds Expectations | 452 |
| #328 | B+ | Barley Sheaf Elementary School | Flemington | Flemington-Raritan Regional School District | 60% | 37% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 401 |
| #329 | B+ | Brookside Elementary School | Westwood | Westwood Regional School District | 60% | 43% | Exceeds Expectations | 401 |
| #330 | B+ | Conover Road Elementary School | Colts Neck | Colts Neck Township School District | 60% | 49% | Meets Expectations | 319 |
| #331 | B+ | Copper Hill Elementary School | Ringoes | Flemington-Raritan Regional School District | 60% | 43% | Exceeds Expectations | 528 |
| #332 | B+ | East Brook Elementary School | Park Ridge | Park Ridge School District | 60% | 41% | Exceeds Expectations | 331 |
| #333 | B+ | Fairview Elementary School | Red Bank | Middletown Township Public School District | 60% | 42% | Exceeds Expectations | 302 |
| #334 | B+ | G Harold Antrim Elementary School | Point Pleasant Beach | Point Pleasant Beach School District | 60% | 41% | Exceeds Expectations | 315 |
| #335 | B+ | Jefferson Elementary School | Summit | Summit Public School District | 60% | 34% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 215 |
| #336 | B+ | Normandy Park School | Morristown | Morris School District | 60% | 34% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 347 |
| #337 | B+ | Oak Tree Road Elementary School | Iselin | Woodbridge Township School District | 60% | 45% | Meets Expectations | 425 |
| #338 | B+ | Old Farmers Road School | Long Valley | Washington Township School District | 60% | 40% | Exceeds Expectations | 317 |
| #339 | B+ | Samuel R Donald Elementary School | Bloomingdale | Bloomingdale School District | 60% | 25% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 188 |
| #340 | B+ | School 5 | Cliffside Park | Cliffside Park School District | 60% | 24% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 277 |
| #341 | B+ | School 9 | Clifton | Clifton Public School District | 60% | 33% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 282 |
| #342 | B+ | Taylor Mills School | Manalapan | Manalapan-Englishtown Regional School District | 60% | 45% | Meets Expectations | 558 |
| #343 | B+ | Ventnor Elementary School | Ventnor | Ventnor City School District | 60% | 27% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 304 |
| #344 | B+ | Washington School | Rutherford | Rutherford School District | 60% | 42% | Exceeds Expectations | 314 |
| #345 | B+ | Benedict A Cucinella School | Long Valley | Washington Township School District | 59% | 48% | Meets Expectations | 492 |
| #346 | B+ | Bertrand F Gibbs Elementary School | New Milford | New Milford Public School District | 59% | 34% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 491 |
| #347 | B+ | Brookside Elementary School | Monroe Township | Monroe Township School District | 59% | 54% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 391 |
| #348 | B+ | Ethel M Burke Elementary School | Bellmawr | Bellmawr Public School District | 59% | 23% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 236 |
| #349 | B+ | Flocktown Kossmann Elementary School | Long Valley | Washington Township School District | 59% | 39% | Exceeds Expectations | 492 |
| #350 | B+ | High Bridge Elementary School High | Bridge | High Bridge Borough School District | 59% | 28% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 209 |
| #351 | B+ | Indian Fields Elementary School | Dayton | South Brunswick School District | 59% | 51% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 565 |
| #352 | B+ | Island Heights Elementary School | Island Heights | Island Heights School District | 59% | 39% | Exceeds Expectations | 131 |
| #353 | B+ | Joyce Kilmer School | Mahwah | Mahwah Township Public School District | 59% | 43% | Meets Expectations | 375 |
| #354 | B+ | Lake Hiawatha Elementary School | Lake Hiawatha | Parsippany-Troy Hills Township School District | 59% | 43% | Meets Expectations | 449 |
| #355 | B+ | Mannington Township Elementary School | Salem | Mannington Township School District | 59% | 32% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 171 |
| #356 | B+ | Mansfield Township Elementary School | Columbus | Mansfield Township School District | 59% | 34% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 300 |
| #357 | B+ | Millstone Township Elementary School | Clarksburg | Millstone Township School District | 59% | 43% | Meets Expectations | 385 |
| #358 | B+ | North Boulevard School | Pompton Plains | Pequannock Township School District | 59% | 41% | Exceeds Expectations | 335 |
| #359 | B+ | Pines Lake Elementary School | Wayne | Wayne Township Public School District | 59% | 47% | Meets Expectations | 387 |
| #360 | B+ | Raritan Valley School | Hazlet | Hazlet Township Public School District | 59% | 32% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 251 |
| #361 | B+ | School One Elementary | Scotch Plains | Scotch Plains-Fanwood School District | 59% | 41% | Exceeds Expectations | 406 |
| #362 | B+ | Shongum School | Randolph | Randolph Township School District | 59% | 57% | Underperforms Expectations | 437 |
| #363 | B+ | Sicomac Elementary School | Wyckoff | Wyckoff Township Public School District | 59% | 47% | Meets Expectations | 355 |
| #364 | B+ | Spring Garden School | Nutley | Nutley Public School District | 59% | 40% | Exceeds Expectations | 453 |
| #365 | B+ | Thomas G Connors Elementary School | Hoboken | Hoboken Public School District | 59% | 36% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 309 |
| #366 | B+ | Woodcrest Elementary School | Cherry Hill | Cherry Hill School District | 59% | 44% | Meets Expectations | 360 |
| #367 | B+ | Abraham Lincoln Elementary School | Wyckoff | Wyckoff Township Public School District | 58% | 44% | Meets Expectations | 333 |
| #368 | B+ | Adamsville Primary School | Bridgewater | Bridgewater-Raritan Regional School District | 58% | 36% | Exceeds Expectations | 490 |
| #369 | B+ | Alan B Shepard Elementary School | Old Bridge | Old Bridge Township School District | 58% | 32% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 280 |
| #370 | B+ | George Washington Elementary School | Wyckoff | Wyckoff Township Public School District | 58% | 56% | Underperforms Expectations | 380 |
| #371 | B+ | Heights Elementary School | Oakland | Oakland Public School District | 58% | 42% | Meets Expectations | 357 |
| #372 | B+ | Hillside Avenue School | Cranford | Cranford Public School District | 58% | 38% | Exceeds Expectations | 734 |
| #373 | B+ | Julia A Traphagen School | Waldwick | Waldwick School District | 58% | 40% | Exceeds Expectations | 425 |
| #374 | B+ | Knollwood Elementary School | Lake Hiawatha | Parsippany-Troy Hills Township School District | 58% | 40% | Exceeds Expectations | 358 |
| #375 | B+ | Lincoln Elementary School | Dumont | Dumont Public School District | 58% | 34% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 190 |
| #376 | B+ | Marian E Mckeown Elementary School | Newton | Hampton Township School District | 58% | 32% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 323 |
| #377 | B+ | Mohawk Avenue School | Sparta | Sparta Township Public School District | 58% | 37% | Exceeds Expectations | 220 |
| #378 | B+ | Northvale Public School | Northvale | Northvale Public School District | 58% | 45% | Meets Expectations | 533 |
| #379 | B+ | Norwood Public School | Norwood | Norwood Public School District | 58% | 52% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 610 |
| #380 | B+ | Randall Carter Elementary School | Wayne | Wayne Township Public School District | 58% | 36% | Exceeds Expectations | 309 |
| #381 | B+ | Ravine Drive Elementary School | Matawan | Matawan-Aberdeen Regional School District | 58% | 33% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 373 |
| #382 | B+ | Salome H Long Memorial School | Saddle Brook | Saddle Brook School District | 58% | 31% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 299 |
| #383 | B+ | Sandshore Rd Elementary School | Budd Lake | Mount Olive Township School District | 58% | 43% | Meets Expectations | 444 |
| #384 | B+ | Tewksbury Elementary School | Califon | Tewksbury Township School District | 58% | 50% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 265 |
| #385 | B+ | West Freehold School | Freehold | Freehold Township School District | 58% | 32% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 404 |
| #386 | B+ | Whitman Elementary School | Turnersville | Washington Township School District | 58% | 30% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 519 |
| #387 | B+ | Yardville Elementary School | Hamilton | Hamilton Township Public School District | 58% | 27% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 317 |
| #388 | B+ | Brielle Elementary School | Brielle | Brielle Boro School District | 57% | 43% | Meets Expectations | 487 |
| #389 | B+ | Eleanor Van Gelder | Edgewater | Edgewater School District | 57% | 48% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 341 |
| #390 | B+ | Evergreen Elementary School | Scotch Plains | Scotch Plains-Fanwood School District | 57% | 41% | Meets Expectations | 405 |
| #391 | B+ | Harry S Truman Elementary School | Parlin | Sayreville School District | 57% | 29% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 440 |
| #392 | B+ | Horace Mann Elementary School | Cherry Hill | Cherry Hill School District | 57% | 30% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 257 |
| #393 | B+ | Hudson Elementary School | Union City | Union City School District | 57% | 28% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 295 |
| #394 | B+ | Hurffville Elementary School | Sewell | Washington Township School District | 57% | 30% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 570 |
| #395 | B+ | James A Garfield Elementary School | Collingswood | Collingswood Public School District | 57% | 26% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 128 |
| #396 | B+ | James Madison School 10 | Garfield | Garfield Public School District | 57% | 14% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 247 |
| #397 | B+ | Lincoln Elementary School | Caldwell | Caldwell-West School District | 57% | 39% | Exceeds Expectations | 259 |
| #398 | B+ | Little Falls Township Public School 3 | Little Falls | Little Falls Township Public School District | 57% | 29% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 173 |
| #399 | B+ | Lynn Crest Elementary School | Colonia | Woodbridge Township School District | 57% | 35% | Exceeds Expectations | 316 |
| #400 | B+ | Milford Brook School | Manalapan | Manalapan-Englishtown Regional School District | 57% | 35% | Exceeds Expectations | 515 |
| #401 | B+ | Northfield Community Elementary School | Northfield | Northfield City School District | 57% | 28% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 446 |
| #402 | B+ | Randolphville Elementary School | Piscataway | Piscataway Township School District | 57% | 35% | Exceeds Expectations | 445 |
| #403 | B+ | Springville Elementary School | Mt Laurel | Mount Laurel Township School District | 57% | 45% | Meets Expectations | 464 |
| #404 | B+ | Stephen J Gerace School | Pequannock | Pequannock Township School District | 57% | 40% | Exceeds Expectations | 303 |
| #405 | B+ | Stony Brook School | Branchburg | Branchburg Township School District | 57% | 44% | Meets Expectations | 286 |
| #406 | B+ | Washington Elementary | Union | Township of Union School District | 57% | 26% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 572 |
| #407 | B+ | William Mason School | Montville | Montville Township School District | 57% | 47% | Meets Expectations | 277 |
| #408 | B+ | William P Tatem Elementary School | Collingswood | Collingswood Public School District | 57% | 33% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 256 |
| #409 | B+ | Winston S Churchill School | Fairfield | Fairfield Public School District | 57% | 50% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 384 |
| #410 | B+ | Chittick Elementary School | East Brunswick | East Brunswick Township School District | 56% | 31% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 392 |
| #411 | B+ | Eleanor Rush Intermediate School | Cinnaminson | Cinnaminson Township School District | 56% | 29% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 601 |
| #412 | B+ | Franklin Elementary School | South Plainfield | South Plainfield School District | 56% | 26% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 282 |
| #413 | B+ | Frederic N Brown Elementary School | Verona | Verona Public School District | 56% | 36% | Exceeds Expectations | 263 |
| #414 | B+ | Glenview Avenue | Haddon Heights | HADDON HEIGHTS School District | 56% | 35% | Exceeds Expectations | 247 |
| #415 | B+ | Ironia School | Randolph | Randolph Township School District | 56% | 58% | Underperforms Expectations | 479 |
| #416 | B+ | Jefferson Elementary School | Succasunna | Roxbury Township School District | 56% | 41% | Meets Expectations | 358 |
| #417 | B+ | Mark Newbie Elementary School | Collingswood | Collingswood Public School District | 56% | 22% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 135 |
| #418 | B+ | Marshall W Errickson School | Freehold | Freehold Township School District | 56% | 39% | Exceeds Expectations | 450 |
| #419 | B+ | Martin Luther King Elementary School | Piscataway | Piscataway Township School District | 56% | 37% | Exceeds Expectations | 484 |
| #420 | B+ | Memorial Elementary School | East Brunswick | East Brunswick Township School District | 56% | 41% | Meets Expectations | 425 |
| #421 | B+ | Memorial School | Emerson | Emerson Public School District | 56% | 44% | Meets Expectations | 362 |
| #422 | B+ | Robert Hunter Elementary School | Flemington | Flemington-Raritan Regional School District | 56% | 39% | Exceeds Expectations | 404 |
| #423 | B+ | Seventh Avenue | Haddon Heights | HADDON HEIGHTS School District | 56% | 38% | Exceeds Expectations | 145 |
| #424 | B+ | Neeta School | Medford Lakes | Medford Lakes School District | 55% | 39% | Exceeds Expectations | 326 |
| #425 | B+ | Eisenhower Intermediate School | Bridgewater | Bridgewater-Raritan Regional School District | 54% | 43% | Meets Expectations | 627 |
| #426 | B+ | Hillside Intermediate School | Bridgewater | Bridgewater-Raritan Regional School District | 54% | 46% | Meets Expectations | 555 |
| #427 | B+ | Mount Arlington Public School | Mt Arlington | Mount Arlington Public School District | 53% | 27% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 199 |
| #428 | B+ | Passaic Gifted And Talented Academy School No 20 | Passaic | Passaic City School District | 53% | 28% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 756 |
| #429 | B | Eleanor G Hewitt | Ringwood | Ringwood School District | 56% | 32% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 231 |
| #430 | B | Harmony Elementary School | New Monmouth | Middletown Township Public School District | 56% | 33% | Exceeds Expectations | 472 |
| #431 | B | Michelle Obama Elementary School | Newark | Newark Public School District | 56% | 10% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 131 |
| #432 | B | Strathmore Elementary School | Aberdeen | Matawan-Aberdeen Regional School District | 56% | 32% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 510 |
| #433 | B | Tinc Rd Elementary School | Flanders | Mount Olive Township School District | 56% | 29% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 464 |
| #434 | B | Washington Elementary School | Township Of Washington | Westwood Regional School District | 56% | 43% | Meets Expectations | 329 |
| #435 | B | Wilson Elementary School | West Caldwell | Caldwell-West School District | 56% | 35% | Exceeds Expectations | 233 |
| #436 | B | Apshawa Elementary School | West Milford | West Milford Township Public School District | 55% | 31% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 207 |
| #437 | B | Bloomsbury Borough School | Bloomsbury | Bloomsbury Borough School District | 55% | 27% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 96 |
| #438 | B | C Richard Applegate School | Freehold | Freehold Township School District | 55% | 37% | Exceeds Expectations | 366 |
| #439 | B | Central Elementary School | Wall | Wall Township Public School District | 55% | 41% | Meets Expectations | 501 |
| #440 | B | Claremont Avenue Elementary School | Colonia | Woodbridge Township School District | 55% | 38% | Exceeds Expectations | 319 |
| #441 | B | Clinton Elementary School | Maplewood | South Orange-Maplewood School District | 55% | 34% | Exceeds Expectations | 550 |
| #442 | B | Constable Elementary School | Kendall Park | South Brunswick School District | 55% | 49% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 513 |
| #443 | B | Frances Demasi Elementary School | Marlton | Evesham Township School District | 55% | 44% | Meets Expectations | 323 |
| #444 | B | James Caldwell Elementary School | Springfield | Springfield Public School District | 55% | 33% | Exceeds Expectations | 219 |
| #445 | B | Learning Community Charter School (Charter) | Jersey City | The Learning Community Charter School | 55% | 38% | Exceeds Expectations | 637 |
| #446 | B | Lincoln Elementary School | Hasbrouck Heights | Hasbrouck Heights School District | 55% | 28% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 384 |
| #447 | B | Logan Township Elementary School | Logan Township | Logan Township School District | 55% | 27% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 284 |
| #448 | B | Manasquan Elementary School | Manasquan | Manasquan School District | 55% | 51% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 499 |
| #449 | B | Mansion Avenue School | Audubon | Audubon Public School District | 55% | 29% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 356 |
| #450 | B | Middletown Village Elementary School | Middletown | Middletown Township Public School District | 55% | 47% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 454 |
| #451 | B | Mountain View Elementary School | Flanders | Mount Olive Township School District | 55% | 35% | Exceeds Expectations | 536 |
| #452 | B | Nellie F Bennett Elementary School | Point Pleasant | Point Pleasant Borough School District | 55% | 44% | Meets Expectations | 719 |
| #453 | B | Paradise Knoll Elementary School | Oak Ridge | West Milford Township Public School District | 55% | 31% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 176 |
| #454 | B | Thelma L Sandmeier Elementary School | Springfield | Springfield Public School District | 55% | 41% | Meets Expectations | 245 |
| #455 | B | West Belmar Elementary School | Wall | Wall Township Public School District | 55% | 28% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 165 |
| #456 | B | Wilson School | Lodi | Lodi School District | 55% | 21% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 356 |
| #457 | B | Bret Harte Elementary School | Cherry Hill | Cherry Hill School District | 54% | 46% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 355 |
| #458 | B | Central Elementary School | East Hanover | East Hanover Township School District | 54% | 46% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 378 |
| #459 | B | Frank K Hehnly | Clark | Clark Township Public School District | 54% | 41% | Meets Expectations | 576 |
| #460 | B | Franklin Elementary School | Bergenfield | Bergenfield Borough School District | 54% | 26% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 346 |
| #461 | B | General Charles G Harker School | Woolwich Township | Swedesboro-Woolwich School District | 54% | 36% | Exceeds Expectations | 649 |
| #462 | B | John Marshall Elementary School | Edison | Edison Township School District | 54% | 35% | Exceeds Expectations | 742 |
| #463 | B | Joseph J Catena School | Freehold | Freehold Township School District | 54% | 42% | Meets Expectations | 447 |
| #464 | B | Lafayette Elementary School | Wayne | Wayne Township Public School District | 54% | 47% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 311 |
| #465 | B | Lincroft Elementary School | Lincroft | Middletown Township Public School District | 54% | 47% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 481 |
| #466 | B | Millington Elementary School | Millington | Long Hill Township School District | 54% | 46% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 352 |
| #467 | B | Oak Ridge Heights Elementary School | Colonia | Woodbridge Township School District | 54% | 37% | Exceeds Expectations | 276 |
| #468 | B | Parkview School | Milltown | Milltown School District | 54% | 30% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 375 |
| #469 | B | Radcliffe School | Nutley | Nutley Public School District | 54% | 35% | Exceeds Expectations | 363 |
| #470 | B | Robert Erskine School | Ringwood | Ringwood School District | 54% | 31% | Exceeds Expectations | 185 |
| #471 | B | Samuel Mickle School | Mickleton | East Greenwich Township School District | 54% | 42% | Meets Expectations | 726 |
| #472 | B | Thomas Jefferson Elementary School | Hawthorne | Hawthorne Public School District | 54% | 35% | Exceeds Expectations | 266 |
| #473 | B | Walter M Schirra Elementary School | Old Bridge | Old Bridge Township School District | 54% | 39% | Meets Expectations | 269 |
| #474 | B | Willow Grove Elementary School | Hackettstown | Hackettstown Public School District | 54% | 24% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 369 |
| #475 | B | Ben Franklin Elementary | Lawrenceville | Lawrence Township Public School District | 53% | 42% | Meets Expectations | 335 |
| #476 | B | Berkley Street School | New Milford | New Milford Public School District | 53% | 36% | Exceeds Expectations | 431 |
| #477 | B | Byram Lakes Elementary School | Stanhope | Byram Township School District | 53% | 35% | Exceeds Expectations | 453 |
| #478 | B | Centre City Elementary School | Mantua | Mantua Township School District | 53% | 28% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 492 |
| #479 | B | Dr Michael Conti School | Jersey City | Jersey City Public Schools | 53% | 34% | Exceeds Expectations | 672 |
| #480 | B | Green Hills School | Greendell | Green Township School District | 53% | 38% | Meets Expectations | 368 |
| #481 | B | James Russell Lowell Elementary School | Teaneck | Teaneck School District | 53% | 21% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 325 |
| #482 | B | John E Riley Elementary School | South Plainfield | South Plainfield School District | 53% | 26% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 381 |
| #483 | B | Laura Donovan School | Freehold | Freehold Township School District | 53% | 39% | Meets Expectations | 449 |
| #484 | B | Memorial School | Maywood | Maywood School District | 53% | 31% | Exceeds Expectations | 431 |
| #485 | B | Osage School | Voorhees | Voorhees Township School District | 53% | 31% | Exceeds Expectations | 551 |
| #486 | B | Radix Elementary | Williamstown | Monroe Township Public School District | 53% | 30% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 619 |
| #487 | B | Rolling Hills Primary School | Vernon | Vernon Township School District | 53% | 27% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 410 |
| #488 | B | Stillwater Township School | Stillwater | Stillwater Township School District | 53% | 31% | Exceeds Expectations | 282 |
| #489 | B | Thomas Jefferson School | Morristown | Morris School District | 53% | 31% | Exceeds Expectations | 275 |
| #490 | B | Upper Township Elementary School | Marmora | Upper Township School District | 53% | 33% | Exceeds Expectations | 437 |
| #491 | B | Washington Irving School 4 | Garfield | Garfield Public School District | 53% | 25% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 347 |
| #492 | B | Washington School | Nutley | Nutley Public School District | 53% | 31% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 516 |
| #493 | B | Aaron Decker School | Butler | Butler Public School District | 52% | 28% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 366 |
| #494 | B | Chesterfield Township Elementary School | Chesterfield | Chesterfield Township School District | 52% | 50% | Underperforms Expectations | 715 |
| #495 | B | Clinton Public School | Clinton | Clinton-Glen Gardner School District | 52% | 34% | Exceeds Expectations | 450 |
| #496 | B | Columbus School | Lodi | Lodi School District | 52% | 19% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 257 |
| #497 | B | George B Fine Elementary School | Pennsauken | Pennsauken Township Board of Education School District | 52% | 11% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 282 |
| #498 | B | Honiss Elementarymiddle School | Dumont | Dumont Public School District | 52% | 35% | Exceeds Expectations | 616 |
| #499 | B | Kingwood Township School | Frenchtown | Kingwood Township School District | 52% | 38% | Meets Expectations | 325 |
| #500 | B | Nathaniel Hawthorne Elementary School | Teaneck | Teaneck School District | 52% | 23% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 274 |