| #1 | A+ | Dr Ronald Mcnair High School | Jersey City | Jersey City Public Schools | 85% | 55% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 701 |
| #2 | A | Millburn High School | Millburn | Millburn Township School District | 74% | 68% | Exceeds Expectations | 1,378 |
| #3 | A | Ridge High School | Basking Ridge | Bernards Township School District | 70% | 57% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 1,682 |
| #4 | A | West Windsor Plainsboro High School North | Plainsboro | West Windsor-Plainsboro Regional School District | 70% | 53% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 1,486 |
| #5 | A | West Windsor Plainsboro High School South | West Windsor | West Windsor-Plainsboro Regional School District | 68% | 51% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 1,630 |
| #6 | A | Thomas Edison Energysmart Charter School (Charter, K-12) | Somerset | Thomas Edison EnergySmart Charter School | 64% | 42% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 604 |
| #7 | A- | Chatham High School | Chatham | School District of the Chathams | 65% | 63% | Meets Expectations | 1,231 |
| #8 | A- | Infinity Institute | Jersey City | Jersey City Public Schools | 64% | 52% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 326 |
| #9 | A- | New Providence High School | New Providence | New Providence School District | 64% | 56% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 666 |
| #10 | A- | Moorestown High School | Moorestown | Moorestown Township Public School District | 63% | 55% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 1,267 |
| #11 | A- | Ridgewood High School | Ridgewood | Ridgewood Public School District | 63% | 58% | Exceeds Expectations | 1,746 |
| #12 | A- | Summit High School | Summit | Summit Public School District | 63% | 55% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 1,161 |
| #13 | A- | Tenafly High School | Tenafly | Tenafly Public School District | 63% | 61% | Exceeds Expectations | 1,200 |
| #14 | A- | Northern Valley Regional High School At Demarest | Demarest | Northern Valley Regional High School District | 62% | 60% | Exceeds Expectations | 978 |
| #15 | A- | West Morris Mendham High School | Mendham | West Morris Regional High School District | 62% | 57% | Exceeds Expectations | 1,077 |
| #16 | A- | Westfield Senior High School | Westfield | Westfield Public School District | 62% | 58% | Exceeds Expectations | 1,818 |
| #17 | A- | John P Stevens High School | Edison | Edison Township School District | 61% | 52% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 2,680 |
| #18 | A- | Princeton High School | Princeton | Princeton Public School District | 60% | 49% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 1,532 |
| #19 | A- | Glen Ridge High School | Glen Ridge | Glen Ridge Public School District | 59% | 54% | Exceeds Expectations | 822 |
| #20 | A- | Livingston High School | Livingston | Livingston Board of Education School District | 59% | 60% | Meets Expectations | 2,066 |
| #21 | A- | Montgomery High School | Skillman | Montgomery Township School District | 59% | 58% | Meets Expectations | 1,603 |
| #22 | A- | Rumson Fair Haven Regional High School | Rumson | Rumson-Fair Haven Regional High School District | 59% | 58% | Meets Expectations | 876 |
| #23 | A- | Central Jersey College Prep Charter School (Charter, K-12) | Somerset | Central Jersey College Prep Charter School | 51% | 37% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 1,288 |
| #24 | B+ | Cresskill High School | Cresskill | Cresskill Public School District | 58% | 56% | Exceeds Expectations | 474 |
| #25 | B+ | Glen Rock High School | Glen Rock | Glen Rock Public School District | 58% | 57% | Meets Expectations | 729 |
| #26 | B+ | Haddonfield Memorial High School | Haddonfield | Haddonfield School District | 57% | 55% | Meets Expectations | 866 |
| #27 | B+ | Holmdel High School | Holmdel | Holmdel Township School District | 57% | 54% | Exceeds Expectations | 932 |
| #28 | B+ | Stem Innovation Academy Of The Oranges | South Orange | ORANGE BOARD OF EDUCATION School District | 57% | 37% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 162 |
| #29 | B+ | Northern Valley Regional High School At Old Tappan | Old Tappan | Northern Valley Regional High School District | 56% | 56% | Meets Expectations | 1,002 |
| #30 | B+ | Hillsborough High School | Hillsborough | Hillsborough Township Public School District | 55% | 51% | Exceeds Expectations | 2,368 |
| #31 | B+ | Northern Highlands Regional High School | Allendale | Northern Highlands Regional High School District | 54% | 55% | Meets Expectations | 1,287 |
| #32 | B+ | Pascack Hills High School | Montvale | Pascack Valley Regional High School District | 54% | 55% | Meets Expectations | 788 |
| #33 | B+ | River Dell Regional High School | Oradell | River Dell Regional School District | 54% | 51% | Exceeds Expectations | 982 |
| #34 | B+ | West Morris Central High School | Chester | West Morris Regional High School District | 54% | 52% | Exceeds Expectations | 994 |
| #35 | B+ | Cranford High School | Cranford | Cranford Public School District | 53% | 49% | Exceeds Expectations | 1,095 |
| #36 | B+ | Fair Lawn High School | Fair Lawn | Fair Lawn Public School District | 53% | 44% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 1,624 |
| #37 | B+ | Hopewell Valley Central High School | Pennington | Hopewell Valley Regional School District | 53% | 52% | Meets Expectations | 1,079 |
| #38 | B+ | Jose Marti Stem Academy | Union City | Union City School District | 53% | 52% | Meets Expectations | 664 |
| #39 | B+ | Madison High School | Madison | Madison Public School District | 53% | 50% | Exceeds Expectations | 824 |
| #40 | B+ | North Hunterdon High School | Annandale | North Hunterdon-Voorhees Regional High School District | 53% | 50% | Exceeds Expectations | 1,237 |
| #41 | B+ | Science Park High School | Newark | Newark Public School District | 53% | 48% | Exceeds Expectations | 938 |
| #42 | B+ | West Essex High School | North Caldwell | West Essex Regional School District | 53% | 52% | Meets Expectations | 1,043 |
| #43 | B+ | Kinnelon High School | Kinnelon | Kinnelon School District | 52% | 48% | Exceeds Expectations | 532 |
| #44 | B+ | Metuchen High School | Metuchen | Metuchen Public School District | 52% | 50% | Exceeds Expectations | 708 |
| #45 | B+ | Montclair High School | Montclair | Montclair Public School District | 52% | 46% | Exceeds Expectations | 1,968 |
| #46 | B+ | Indian Hills High School | Oakland | Ramapo Indian Hills Regional High School District | 51% | 50% | Meets Expectations | 736 |
| #47 | B+ | Mahwah High School | Mahwah | Mahwah Township Public School District | 51% | 50% | Meets Expectations | 856 |
| #48 | B+ | Montville Township High School | Montville | Montville Township School District | 51% | 51% | Meets Expectations | 1,112 |
| #49 | B+ | Scotch Plains Fanwood High School | Scotch Plains | Scotch Plains-Fanwood School District | 51% | 49% | Exceeds Expectations | 1,510 |
| #50 | B+ | Watchung Hills Regional High School | Warren | Watchung Hills Regional High School District | 51% | 54% | Meets Expectations | 1,741 |
| #51 | B | Bernards High School | Bernardsville | Somerset Hills Regional School District | 50% | 51% | Meets Expectations | 812 |
| #52 | B | Governor Livingston High School | Berkeley Heights | Berkeley Heights School District | 50% | 52% | Meets Expectations | 936 |
| #53 | B | Park Ridge High School | Park Ridge | Park Ridge School District | 50% | 48% | Meets Expectations | 512 |
| #54 | B | Ramapo High School | Franklin Lakes | Ramapo Indian Hills Regional High School District | 49% | 59% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 1,243 |
| #55 | B | Sparta High School | Sparta | Sparta Township Public School District | 49% | 47% | Exceeds Expectations | 1,071 |
| #56 | B | Monroe Township High School | Monroe Township | Monroe Township School District | 48% | 46% | Exceeds Expectations | 2,568 |
| #57 | B | Parsippany Hills High School | Morris Plains | Parsippany-Troy Hills Township School District | 48% | 49% | Meets Expectations | 998 |
| #58 | B | Robbinsville High School | Robbinsville | Robbinsville Public School District | 48% | 48% | Meets Expectations | 1,057 |
| #59 | B | Shawnee High School | Medford | Lenape Regional High School District | 48% | 47% | Meets Expectations | 1,465 |
| #60 | B | Wayne Valley High School | Wayne | Wayne Township Public School District | 48% | 45% | Exceeds Expectations | 1,241 |
| #61 | B | Cherry Hill High School East | Cherry Hill | Cherry Hill School District | 47% | 46% | Meets Expectations | 2,087 |
| #62 | B | Elizabeth High School Frank J Cicarell Academy | Elizabeth | Elizabeth Public Schools | 47% | 53% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 1,281 |
| #63 | B | Fort Lee High School | Fort Lee | Fort Lee School District | 47% | 46% | Meets Expectations | 1,160 |
| #64 | B | Haddon Township High School | Westmont | Haddon Township School District | 47% | 46% | Meets Expectations | 628 |
| #65 | B | Marlboro High School | Marlboro | Freehold Regional High School District | 47% | 48% | Meets Expectations | 1,816 |
| #66 | B | South Brunswick High School | Monmouth Junction | South Brunswick School District | 47% | 48% | Meets Expectations | 2,786 |
| #67 | B | Wayne Hills High School | Wayne | Wayne Township Public School District | 47% | 47% | Meets Expectations | 1,182 |
| #68 | B | Colts Neck High School | Colts Neck | Freehold Regional High School District | 46% | 47% | Meets Expectations | 1,432 |
| #69 | B | Whippany Park High School | Whippany | Hanover Park Regional High School District | 46% | 49% | Meets Expectations | 595 |
| #70 | B- | Columbia High School | Maplewood | South Orange-Maplewood School District | 45% | 44% | Meets Expectations | 1,930 |
| #71 | B- | Eastern Regional High School | Voorhees | Eastern Camden County Regional School District | 45% | 45% | Meets Expectations | 1,933 |
| #72 | B- | Hunterdon Central Regional High School District | Flemington | Hunterdon Central Regional High School District | 45% | 43% | Exceeds Expectations | 2,486 |
| #73 | B- | James Caldwell High School | West Caldwell | Caldwell-West School District | 45% | 46% | Meets Expectations | 789 |
| #74 | B- | Pascack Valley High School | Hillsdale | Pascack Valley Regional High School District | 45% | 49% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 984 |
| #75 | B- | Roxbury High School | Succasunna | Roxbury Township School District | 45% | 41% | Exceeds Expectations | 1,192 |
| #76 | B- | Technology High School | Newark | Newark Public School District | 45% | 41% | Exceeds Expectations | 665 |
| #77 | B- | Allentown High School | Allentown | Upper Freehold Regional School District | 44% | 46% | Meets Expectations | 1,084 |
| #78 | B- | Bridgewater Raritan High School | Bridgewater | Bridgewater-Raritan Regional School District | 44% | 45% | Meets Expectations | 2,711 |
| #79 | B- | Delaware Valley Regional High School | Frenchtown | Delaware Valley Regional High School District | 44% | 43% | Meets Expectations | 722 |
| #80 | B- | Mount Olive High School | Flanders | Mount Olive Township School District | 44% | 40% | Exceeds Expectations | 1,493 |
| #81 | B- | Voorhees High School | Glen Gardner | North Hunterdon-Voorhees Regional High School District | 44% | 45% | Meets Expectations | 672 |
| #82 | B- | Dumont High School | Dumont | Dumont Public School District | 43% | 45% | Meets Expectations | 761 |
| #83 | B- | Hackettstown High School | Hackettstown | Hackettstown Public School District | 43% | 37% | Exceeds Expectations | 926 |
| #84 | B- | Hanover Park High School | East Hanover | Hanover Park Regional High School District | 43% | 47% | Meets Expectations | 731 |
| #85 | B- | Leonia High School | Leonia | Leonia Public School District | 43% | 42% | Meets Expectations | 847 |
| #86 | B- | Manasquan High School | Manasquan | Manasquan School District | 43% | 45% | Meets Expectations | 948 |
| #87 | B- | Middletown High School South | Middletown | Middletown Township Public School District | 43% | 43% | Meets Expectations | 1,474 |
| #88 | B- | Ocean City High School | Ocean City | Ocean City School District | 43% | 48% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 1,215 |
| #89 | B- | Lenape Valley Regional High School | Stanhope | Lenape Valley Regional High School District | 42% | 41% | Meets Expectations | 667 |
| #90 | B- | Midland Park Jrsr High School | Midland Park | Midland Park School District | 42% | 42% | Meets Expectations | 327 |
| #91 | B- | Verona High School | Verona | Verona Public School District | 42% | 46% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 637 |
| #92 | B- | Westwood Regional High School | Township Of Washington | Westwood Regional School District | 42% | 44% | Meets Expectations | 841 |
| #93 | B- | Freehold Township High School | Freehold Twp | Freehold Regional High School District | 41% | 41% | Meets Expectations | 1,926 |
| #94 | B- | John F Kennedy Memorial High School | Iselin | Woodbridge Township School District | 41% | 40% | Meets Expectations | 1,371 |
| #95 | B- | Lenape High School | Medford | Lenape Regional High School District | 41% | 43% | Meets Expectations | 1,892 |
| #96 | B- | Morris Hills High School | Rockaway | Morris Hills Regional School District | 41% | 42% | Meets Expectations | 1,187 |
| #97 | B- | Morris Knolls High School | Denville | Morris Hills Regional School District | 41% | 42% | Meets Expectations | 1,447 |
| #98 | B- | Northern Burlington County Regional High School | Columbus | Northern Burlington County Regional School District | 41% | 42% | Meets Expectations | 1,427 |
| #99 | B- | Paramus High School | Paramus | Paramus Public School District | 41% | 42% | Meets Expectations | 1,148 |
| #100 | B- | Seneca High School | Tabernacle | Lenape Regional High School District | 41% | 40% | Meets Expectations | 1,018 |
| #101 | B- | South Plainfield High School | South Plainfield | South Plainfield School District | 41% | 37% | Exceeds Expectations | 1,097 |
| #102 | B- | Cherokee High School | Marlton | Lenape Regional High School District | 40% | 44% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 2,179 |
| #103 | B- | Manalapan High School | Englishtown | Freehold Regional High School District | 40% | 44% | Meets Expectations | 1,722 |
| #104 | B- | Beloved Community Charter School (Charter, K-12) | Jersey City | BelovED Community Charter | 35% | 41% | Meets Expectations | 1,551 |
| #105 | B- | Bergen Arts And Sciences Charter School (Charter, K-12) | Garfield | Bergen Arts and Science Charter School | 34% | 32% | Exceeds Expectations | 1,253 |
| #106 | C+ | Highland Park High School | Highland Park | Highland Park Boro School District | 40% | 39% | Meets Expectations | 494 |
| #107 | C+ | Matawan Regional High School | Aberdeen | Matawan-Aberdeen Regional School District | 40% | 39% | Meets Expectations | 1,146 |
| #108 | C+ | Point Pleasant Beach High School | Point Pleasant Beach | Point Pleasant Beach School District | 40% | 52% | Underperforms Expectations | 358 |
| #109 | C+ | Ramsey High School | Ramsey | Ramsey School District | 40% | 45% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 784 |
| #110 | C+ | Cedar Creek High School | Egg Harbor City | Greater Egg Harbor Regional High School District | 39% | 34% | Exceeds Expectations | 929 |
| #111 | C+ | Emerson JR SR High | Emerson | Emerson Public School District | 39% | 48% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 440 |
| #112 | C+ | Mainland Regional High School | Linwood | Mainland Regional High School | 39% | 39% | Meets Expectations | 1,181 |
| #113 | C+ | Old Bridge High School | Matawan | Old Bridge Township School District | 39% | 37% | Exceeds Expectations | 2,707 |
| #114 | C+ | Pequannock Township High School | Pompton Plains | Pequannock Township School District | 39% | 41% | Meets Expectations | 668 |
| #115 | C+ | Point Pleasant Borough High School | Point Pleasant | Point Pleasant Borough School District | 39% | 41% | Meets Expectations | 898 |
| #116 | C+ | Rutherford High School | Rutherford | Rutherford School District | 39% | 44% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 753 |
| #117 | C+ | Somerville High School | Somerville | Somerville Public School District | 39% | 39% | Meets Expectations | 1,109 |
| #118 | C+ | Burlington Township High School | Burlington | Burlington Township School District | 38% | 37% | Exceeds Expectations | 1,187 |
| #119 | C+ | Cinnaminson High School | Cinnaminson | Cinnaminson Township School District | 38% | 46% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 882 |
| #120 | C+ | Delsea Regional High School | Franklinville | Delsea Regional High School District | 38% | 36% | Exceeds Expectations | 1,074 |
| #121 | C+ | Egg Harbor Township High School | Egg Harbor Township | Egg Harbor Township School District | 38% | 35% | Exceeds Expectations | 2,335 |
| #122 | C+ | Howell High School | Farmingdale | Freehold Regional High School District | 38% | 39% | Meets Expectations | 2,011 |
| #123 | C+ | Kingsway Regional High School | Woolwich Twp | Kingsway Regional School District | 38% | 40% | Meets Expectations | 1,947 |
| #124 | C+ | Lawrence High School | Lawrenceville | Lawrence Township Public School District | 38% | 38% | Meets Expectations | 1,207 |
| #125 | C+ | Lodi High School | Lodi | Lodi School District | 38% | 40% | Meets Expectations | 907 |
| #126 | C+ | New Egypt High School | New Egypt | Plumsted Township School District | 38% | 40% | Meets Expectations | 315 |
| #127 | C+ | Parsippany High School | Parsippany | Parsippany-Troy Hills Township School District | 38% | 41% | Meets Expectations | 886 |
| #128 | C+ | Randolph High School | Randolph | Randolph Township School District | 38% | 43% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 1,349 |
| #129 | C+ | Shore Regional High School | West Long Branch | Shore Regional High School District | 38% | 45% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 585 |
| #130 | C+ | Washington Township High School | Sewell | Washington Township School District | 38% | 41% | Meets Expectations | 2,075 |
| #131 | C+ | Cedar Grove High School | Cedar Grove | Cedar Grove Township School District | 37% | 53% | Underperforms Expectations | 466 |
| #132 | C+ | East Orange Stem Academy High School | East Orange | East Orange School District | 37% | 33% | Exceeds Expectations | 568 |
| #133 | C+ | Haddon Heights Jrsr High School | Haddon Heights | HADDON HEIGHTS School District | 37% | 34% | Exceeds Expectations | 983 |
| #134 | C+ | Jackson Memorial High School | Jackson | Jackson Township School District | 37% | 38% | Meets Expectations | 1,499 |
| #135 | C+ | Piscataway Township High School | Piscataway | Piscataway Township School District | 37% | 42% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 2,144 |
| #136 | C+ | West Deptford High School | West Deptford | West Deptford Township School District | 37% | 34% | Exceeds Expectations | 781 |
| #137 | C+ | Dwight Morrow High Schoolacademiesatenglewood | Englewood | Englewood Public School District | 36% | 37% | Meets Expectations | 1,077 |
| #138 | C+ | Freehold Borough High School | Freehold | Freehold Regional High School District | 36% | 39% | Meets Expectations | 1,409 |
| #139 | C+ | Nutley High School | Nutley | Nutley Public School District | 36% | 37% | Meets Expectations | 1,132 |
| #140 | C+ | Passaic Academy For Science And Engineering | Passaic | Passaic City School District | 36% | 38% | Meets Expectations | 745 |
| #141 | C+ | Rancocas Valley Regional High School | Mount Holly | Rancocas Valley Regional High School District | 36% | 36% | Meets Expectations | 1,981 |
| #142 | C+ | Southern Regional High School | Manahawkin | Southern Regional School District | 36% | 37% | Meets Expectations | 1,845 |
| #143 | C+ | Spotswood High School | Spotswood | Spotswood Public School District | 36% | 37% | Meets Expectations | 745 |
| #144 | C+ | Wall High School | Wall | Wall Township Public School District | 36% | 40% | Meets Expectations | 936 |
| #145 | C+ | Wallkill Valley Regional High School | Hardyston Township | Wallkill Valley Regional High School | 36% | 36% | Meets Expectations | 615 |
| #146 | C+ | Arthur P Schalick High School | Pittsgrove | Pittsgrove Township School District | 35% | 35% | Meets Expectations | 495 |
| #147 | C+ | Clearview Regional High School | Mullica Hill | Clearview Regional High School District | 35% | 39% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 1,431 |
| #148 | C+ | Delran High School | Delran | Delran Township School District | 35% | 36% | Meets Expectations | 912 |
| #149 | C+ | Edison High School | Edison | Edison Township School District | 35% | 40% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 2,280 |
| #150 | C+ | Lakeland Regional High School | Wanaque | Lakeland Regional High School District | 35% | 41% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 867 |
| #151 | C+ | Phillipsburg High School | Phillipsburg | Phillipsburg School District | 35% | 39% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 1,794 |
| #152 | C+ | Ridgefield Memorial High School | Ridgefield | Ridgefield School District | 35% | 41% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 533 |
| #153 | C+ | Toms River High School North | Toms River | Toms River Regional School District | 35% | 45% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 1,931 |
| #154 | C+ | Warren Hills Regional High School | Washington | Warren Hills Regional School District | 35% | 36% | Meets Expectations | 1,068 |
| #155 | C+ | North Star Academy Charter School (Charter, K-12) | Newark | North Star Academy Charter School | 29% | 20% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 6,352 |
| #156 | C | Hamilton East Steinert | Hamilton | Hamilton Township Public School District | 34% | 36% | Meets Expectations | 1,427 |
| #157 | C | Hightstown High School | Hightstown | East Windsor Regional School District | 34% | 37% | Meets Expectations | 1,644 |
| #158 | C | Liberty High School | Jersey City | Jersey City Public Schools | 34% | 42% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 194 |
| #159 | C | Morristown High School | Morristown | Morris School District | 34% | 37% | Meets Expectations | 1,868 |
| #160 | C | Vernon Township High School | Vernon | Vernon Township School District | 34% | 35% | Meets Expectations | 929 |
| #161 | C | Weehawken High School | Weehawken | Weehawken Public School District | 34% | 39% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 570 |
| #162 | C | Bergenfield High School | Bergenfield | Bergenfield Borough School District | 33% | 46% | Underperforms Expectations | 1,224 |
| #163 | C | Colonia High School | Colonia | Woodbridge Township School District | 33% | 45% | Underperforms Expectations | 1,356 |
| #164 | C | Florence Township Memorial High School | Burlington | Florence Township School District | 33% | 33% | Meets Expectations | 484 |
| #165 | C | Hasbrouck Heights High School | Hasbrouck Heights | Hasbrouck Heights School District | 33% | 47% | Underperforms Expectations | 547 |
| #166 | C | Kittatinny Regional High School | Newton | Kittatinny Regional School District | 33% | 40% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 781 |
| #167 | C | Middletown High School North | Middletown | Middletown Township Public School District | 33% | 39% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 1,340 |
| #168 | C | North Warren Regional School | Blairstown | North Warren Regional School District | 33% | 36% | Meets Expectations | 620 |
| #169 | C | Pompton Lakes High School | Pompton Lakes | Pompton Lakes School District | 33% | 46% | Underperforms Expectations | 641 |
| #170 | C | Arthur L Johnson High School | Clark | Clark Township Public School District | 32% | 39% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 731 |
| #171 | C | Bloomfield High School | Bloomfield | Bloomfield Township School District | 32% | 31% | Meets Expectations | 2,029 |
| #172 | C | East Brunswick High School (K-12) | East Brunswick | East Brunswick Township School District | 32% | 41% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 2,036 |
| #173 | C | High Point Regional High School District | Sussex | High Point Regional High School District | 32% | 42% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 817 |
| #174 | C | Lacey Township High School | Lanoka Harbor | Lacey Township School District | 32% | 34% | Meets Expectations | 1,222 |
| #175 | C | Red Bank Regional High School | Little Silver | Red Bank Regional School District | 32% | 33% | Meets Expectations | 1,195 |
| #176 | C | Sayreville War Memorial High School | Parlin | Sayreville School District | 32% | 34% | Meets Expectations | 1,750 |
| #177 | C | Waldwick High School | Waldwick | Waldwick School District | 32% | 39% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 424 |
| #178 | C | West Orange High School | West Orange | West Orange Public Schools | 32% | 34% | Meets Expectations | 2,151 |
| #179 | C | Audubon Juniorsenior High School | Audubon | Audubon Public School District | 31% | 33% | Meets Expectations | 758 |
| #180 | C | Bordentown Regional High School | Bordentown | Bordentown Regional School District | 31% | 41% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 763 |
| #181 | C | Hawthorne High School | Hawthorne | Hawthorne Public School District | 31% | 32% | Meets Expectations | 602 |
| #182 | C | Lyndhurst High School | Lyndhurst | Lyndhurst Public School District | 31% | 32% | Meets Expectations | 824 |
| #183 | C | New Milford High School | New Milford | New Milford Public School District | 31% | 38% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 588 |
| #184 | C | North Arlington High School | North Arlington | North Arlington School District | 31% | 35% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 584 |
| #185 | C | Toms River High School East | Toms River | Toms River Regional School District | 31% | 33% | Meets Expectations | 1,520 |
| #186 | C | Lower Cape May Regional High School | Cape May | Lower Cape May Regional School District | 30% | 34% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 757 |
| #187 | C | Teaneck High School | Teaneck | Teaneck School District | 30% | 33% | Meets Expectations | 1,271 |
| #188 | C- | Newark School Of Global Studies | Newark | Newark Public School District | 33% | 26% | Exceeds Expectations | 290 |
| #189 | C- | Absegami High School | Galloway | Greater Egg Harbor Regional High School District | 30% | 30% | Meets Expectations | 1,125 |
| #190 | C- | Bard Early College High School | Newark | Newark Public School District | 30% | 38% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 381 |
| #191 | C- | Butler High School | Butler | Butler Public School District | 30% | 32% | Meets Expectations | 480 |
| #192 | C- | Collingswood High School | Collingswood | Collingswood Public School District | 30% | 33% | Meets Expectations | 809 |
| #193 | C- | Saddle Brook Middlehigh School | Saddle Brook | Saddle Brook School District | 30% | 34% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 810 |
| #194 | C- | Wood Ridge Jrsr High School | Wood Ridge | Wood-Ridge School District | 30% | 39% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 530 |
| #195 | C- | Dover High School | Dover | Dover Public School District | 29% | 30% | Meets Expectations | 1,159 |
| #196 | C- | Hammonton High School | Hammonton | Hammonton School District | 29% | 31% | Meets Expectations | 1,357 |
| #197 | C- | North Brunswick Township High School | North Brunswick | North Brunswick Township School District | 29% | 38% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 1,881 |
| #198 | C- | Ocean Township High School | Oakhurst | Township of Ocean School District | 29% | 38% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 1,021 |
| #199 | C- | Raritan High School | Hazlet | Hazlet Township Public School District | 29% | 33% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 838 |
| #200 | C- | Secaucus High School | Secaucus | Secaucus School District | 29% | 34% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 637 |
| #201 | C- | Union High School | Union | Township of Union School District | 29% | 34% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 2,308 |
| #202 | C- | Williamstown High School | Williamstown | Monroe Township Public School District | 29% | 35% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 1,782 |
| #203 | C- | Woodstown High School | Woodstown | Woodstown-Pilesgrove Regional School District | 29% | 37% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 543 |
| #204 | C- | Barnegat High School | Barnegat | Barnegat Township School District | 28% | 30% | Meets Expectations | 983 |
| #205 | C- | Bogota Jrsr High School | Bogota | Bogota Public School District | 28% | 29% | Meets Expectations | 442 |
| #206 | C- | Carteret High School | Carteret | Carteret Public School District | 28% | 27% | Meets Expectations | 1,089 |
| #207 | C- | Cliffside Park High School | Cliffside Park | Cliffside Park School District | 28% | 35% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 1,240 |
| #208 | C- | Dunellen High School | Dunellen | Dunellen Public School District | 28% | 40% | Underperforms Expectations | 389 |
| #209 | C- | Henry P Becton Regional High School | East Rutherford | Carlstadt-East Rutherford Regional High School District | 28% | 42% | Underperforms Expectations | 771 |
| #210 | C- | Jackson Liberty High School | Jackson | Jackson Township School District | 28% | 31% | Meets Expectations | 1,141 |
| #211 | C- | Monmouth Regional High School | Tinton Falls | Monmouth Regional High School | 28% | 37% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 938 |
| #212 | C- | Newton High School | Newton | Newton Public School District | 28% | 34% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 719 |
| #213 | C- | Palmyra High School | Palmyra | Palmyra Public School District | 28% | 32% | Meets Expectations | 388 |
| #214 | C- | Passaic Valley Regional High School | Little Falls | Passaic Valley Regional High School District | 28% | 34% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 1,039 |
| #215 | C- | Wallington Junior Senior High School | Wallington | Wallington Boro School District | 28% | 38% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 571 |
| #216 | C- | West Milford High School | West Milford | West Milford Township Public School District | 28% | 60% | Underperforms Expectations | 935 |
| #217 | C- | Woodbridge High School | Woodbridge | Woodbridge Township School District | 28% | 41% | Underperforms Expectations | 1,558 |
| #218 | C- | Belvidere High School | Belvidere | Belvidere School District | 27% | 40% | Underperforms Expectations | 346 |
| #219 | C- | Boonton High School | Boonton | Boonton Town Public School District | 27% | 32% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 662 |
| #220 | C- | Brick Township High School | Brick Town | Brick Township Public School District | 27% | 30% | Meets Expectations | 1,267 |
| #221 | C- | Ewing High School | Ewing | Ewing Township School District | 27% | 28% | Meets Expectations | 1,109 |
| #222 | C- | Hackensack High School | Hackensack | Hackensack School District | 27% | 29% | Meets Expectations | 1,745 |
| #223 | C- | Hamilton West Watson | Hamilton | Hamilton Township Public School District | 27% | 28% | Meets Expectations | 1,348 |
| #224 | C- | Jefferson Township High School | Oak Ridge | Jefferson Township Public School District | 27% | 35% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 826 |
| #225 | C- | Middlesex High School | Middlesex | Middlesex Borough School District | 27% | 33% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 619 |
| #226 | C- | Pinelands Regional High School | Little Egg Harbor | Pinelands Regional School District | 27% | 34% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 1,069 |
| #227 | C- | Toms River High School South | Toms River | Toms River Regional School District | 27% | 30% | Meets Expectations | 1,359 |
| #228 | C- | Bayonne High School | Bayonne | Bayonne School District | 26% | 33% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 2,656 |
| #229 | C- | Cherry Hill High School West | Cherry Hill | Cherry Hill School District | 26% | 31% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 1,355 |
| #230 | C- | Hamilton North Nottingham | Hamilton | Hamilton Township Public School District | 26% | 31% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 1,005 |
| #231 | C- | Hopatcong High School | Hopatcong | Hopatcong Borough School District | 26% | 31% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 520 |
| #232 | C- | South Hunterdon Regional High School | Lambertville | South Hunterdon Regional School District | 26% | 34% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 417 |
| #233 | C- | Sterling High School | Somerdale | Sterling Regional School District | 26% | 31% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 894 |
| #234 | C- | Alexander Hamilton Preparatory Academy | Elizabeth | Elizabeth Public Schools | 25% | 40% | Underperforms Expectations | 996 |
| #235 | C- | Great Oaks Legacy Charter School (Charter, K-12) | Newark | Great Oaks Legacy Charter School | 23% | 18% | Exceeds Expectations | 2,012 |
| #236 | C- | Foundation Academy Charter School (Charter, K-12) | Trenton | Foundation Academy Charter School | 21% | 28% | Meets Expectations | 1,044 |
| #237 | D+ | Arts High School | Newark | Newark Public School District | 25% | 30% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 593 |
| #238 | D+ | Clifton High School | Clifton | Clifton Public School District | 25% | 35% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 3,059 |
| #239 | D+ | Deptford Township High School | Deptford | Deptford Township Public School District | 25% | 44% | Underperforms Expectations | 1,084 |
| #240 | D+ | Franklin High School | Somerset | Franklin Township Public School District | 25% | 42% | Underperforms Expectations | 2,220 |
| #241 | D+ | Kearny High School | Kearny | Kearny | 25% | 29% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 1,827 |
| #242 | D+ | Pitman High School | Pitman | Pitman Boro School District | 25% | 30% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 330 |
| #243 | D+ | South River High School | South River | South River Public School District | 25% | 25% | Meets Expectations | 762 |
| #244 | D+ | Timber Creek Regional High School | Erial | Black Horse Pike Regional School District | 25% | 32% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 1,166 |
| #245 | D+ | Belleville High School | Belleville | Belleville Public School District | 24% | 32% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 1,499 |
| #246 | D+ | Brick Township Memorial High School | Brick | Brick Township Public School District | 24% | 32% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 1,320 |
| #247 | D+ | David Brearley Middlehigh School | Kenilworth | Kenilworth School District | 24% | 32% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 774 |
| #248 | D+ | Gloucester City High School | Gloucester City | Gloucester City Public School District | 24% | 30% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 702 |
| #249 | D+ | Linden High School | Linden | Linden Public School District | 24% | 27% | Meets Expectations | 1,801 |
| #250 | D+ | Manchester Township High School | Manchester | Manchester Township School District | 24% | 26% | Meets Expectations | 959 |
| #251 | D+ | Manville High School | Manville | Manville School District | 24% | 28% | Meets Expectations | 501 |
| #252 | D+ | Palisades Park JR SR High School | Palisades Park | Palisades Park School District | 24% | 28% | Meets Expectations | 745 |
| #253 | D+ | Pemberton Township High School | Pemberton | Pemberton Township School District | 24% | 32% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 1,057 |
| #254 | D+ | South Amboy Middlehigh School | South Amboy | South Amboy School District | 24% | 31% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 571 |
| #255 | D+ | Wildwood High School | Wildwood | Wildwood City School District | 24% | 31% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 263 |
| #256 | D+ | Passaic Arts And Science Charter School (Charter, K-12) | Passaic | Passaic Arts and Science Charter School | 21% | 25% | Meets Expectations | 1,946 |
| #257 | D+ | Union County Teams Charter School (Charter, K-12) | Plainfield | Union County TEAMS Charter School-High School/College LA | 19% | 31% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 334 |
| #258 | D+ | Paterson Arts And Science Charter School (Charter, K-12) | Paterson | Paterson Arts and Science Charter School | 18% | 23% | Meets Expectations | 1,160 |
| #259 | D+ | Team Academy Charter School (Charter, K-12) | Newark | TEAM Academy Charter School | 18% | 18% | Meets Expectations | 6,096 |
| #260 | D+ | The Queen City Academy Charter School (Charter, K-12) | Plainfield | The Queen City Academy Charter School District | 17% | 25% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 403 |
| #261 | D | Central Regional High School | Bayville | Central Regional School District | 23% | 28% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 1,606 |
| #262 | D | Garfield High School | Garfield | Garfield Public School District | 23% | 25% | Meets Expectations | 1,199 |
| #263 | D | Innovation High School | Jersey City | Jersey City Public Schools | 23% | 57% | Underperforms Expectations | 272 |
| #264 | D | Memorial High School | West New York | West New York School District | 23% | 28% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 2,251 |
| #265 | D | Ridgefield Park JR SR High School | Ridgefield Park | Ridgefield Park Public School District | 23% | 34% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 1,174 |
| #266 | D | Rosa L Parks School Of Fine And Performing Arts | Paterson | Paterson Public School District | 23% | 21% | Meets Expectations | 252 |
| #267 | D | Gateway Regional High School | Woodbury Hts | Gateway Regional High School District | 22% | 28% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 849 |
| #268 | D | Highland Regional High School | Blackwood | Black Horse Pike Regional School District | 22% | 47% | Underperforms Expectations | 1,204 |
| #269 | D | Hoboken High School | Hoboken | Hoboken Public School District | 22% | 32% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 526 |
| #270 | D | Millville Senior High School | Millville | Millville School District | 22% | 29% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 1,640 |
| #271 | D | Paterson P Tech | Paterson | Paterson Public School District | 22% | 20% | Exceeds Expectations | 202 |
| #272 | D | Pennsville Memorial High School | Pennsville | Pennsville School District | 22% | 33% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 462 |
| #273 | D | Salem High School | Salem | Salem City School District | 22% | 23% | Meets Expectations | 420 |
| #274 | D | Triton Regional High School | Runnemede | Black Horse Pike Regional School District | 22% | 27% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 1,132 |
| #275 | D | Buena Regional High School | Buena | Buena Regional School District | 21% | 30% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 496 |
| #276 | D | Cicely L Tyson Community Middlehigh School | East Orange | East Orange School District | 21% | 33% | Underperforms Expectations | 711 |
| #277 | D | Clayton High School | Clayton | Clayton Public School District | 21% | 26% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 454 |
| #278 | D | Memorial Senior High School | Elmwood Park | Elmwood Park School District | 21% | 26% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 806 |
| #279 | D | Oakcrest High School | Mays Landing | Greater Egg Harbor Regional High School District | 21% | 27% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 914 |
| #280 | D | Overbrook Senior High School | Pine Hill | Pine Hill School District | 21% | 24% | Meets Expectations | 792 |
| #281 | D | Passaic Preparatory Academy | Passaic | Passaic City School District | 21% | 31% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 713 |
| #282 | D | Pennsauken High School | Pennsauken | Pennsauken Township Board of Education School District | 21% | 23% | Meets Expectations | 1,530 |
| #283 | D | Perth Amboy High School | Perth Amboy | Perth Amboy Public School District | 21% | 23% | Meets Expectations | 2,658 |
| #284 | D | Bayonne Alternative High School | Bayonne | Bayonne School District | 20% | 28% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 180 |
| #285 | D | Glassboro High School | Glassboro | Glassboro School District | 20% | 21% | Meets Expectations | 518 |
| #286 | D | Woodbury JR SR High School | Woodbury | Woodbury City Public School District | 20% | 26% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 829 |
| #287 | D | Lakewood High School | Lakewood | Lakewood Township School District | 19% | 21% | Meets Expectations | 1,423 |
| #288 | D | Middle Township High School | Cape May Court House | Middle Township Public School District | 19% | 27% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 790 |
| #289 | D | Neptune High School | Neptune | Neptune Township School District | 19% | 24% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 1,203 |
| #290 | D | North Bergen High School | N Bergen | North Bergen School District | 19% | 24% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 2,355 |
| #291 | D | North Plainfield High School | North Plainfield | North Plainfield School District | 19% | 24% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 1,214 |
| #292 | D | Passaic County Manchester Regional High School | Haledon | Passaic County Manchester Regional High School District | 19% | 21% | Meets Expectations | 811 |
| #293 | D | Rahway High School | Rahway | Rahway Public School District | 19% | 29% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 1,204 |
| #294 | D | Roselle Park High School | Roselle Park | Roselle Park Public School District | 19% | 25% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 630 |
| #295 | D | Thomas Jefferson Arts Academy | Elizabeth | Elizabeth Public Schools | 19% | 24% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 1,070 |
| #296 | D | Winslow Township High School | Atco | Winslow Township School District | 19% | 23% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 1,273 |
| #297 | D | American History High School | Newark | Newark Public School District | 18% | 26% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 373 |
| #298 | D | Atlantic City High School | Atlantic City | Atlantic City School District | 18% | 20% | Meets Expectations | 1,764 |
| #299 | D | Hillside High School | Hillside | Hillside Public School District | 18% | 21% | Meets Expectations | 925 |
| #300 | D | Long Branch High School | Long Branch | LONG BRANCH PUBLIC SCHOOL District | 18% | 25% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 1,548 |
| #301 | D | Maple Shade High School | Maple Shade | Maple Shade School District | 18% | 30% | Underperforms Expectations | 931 |
| #302 | D | Union City High School | Union City | Union City School District | 18% | 30% | Underperforms Expectations | 3,025 |
| #303 | D | University Academy Charter High School (Charter) | Jersey City | University Academy Charter High School | 18% | 33% | Underperforms Expectations | 432 |
| #304 | D | Vineland Senior High School | Vineland | Vineland Public School District | 18% | 20% | Meets Expectations | 2,780 |
| #305 | D | Camdens Promise Charter School (Charter, K-12) | Camden | Camden's Promise Charter School | 15% | 25% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 2,363 |
| #306 | D | College Achieve Greater Asbury Park Charter School (Charter, K-12) | District Asbury Park | College Achieve Greater Asbury Park Charter School | 15% | 24% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 554 |
| #307 | D | College Achieve Paterson Charter School (Charter, K-12) | Paterson | College Achieve Paterson Charter School | 15% | 20% | Meets Expectations | 1,305 |
| #308 | D | College Achieve Central Charter School (Charter, K-12) | Plainfield | College Achieve Central Charter School | 13% | 32% | Underperforms Expectations | 1,403 |
| #309 | D | Leap Academy University Charter School (Charter, K-12) | Camden | LEAP Academy University Charter School | 13% | 23% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 1,557 |
| #310 | D | Marion P Thomas Charter School (Charter, K-12) | Newark | Marion P. Thomas Charter School | 13% | 22% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 1,425 |
| #311 | D- | International High School | Paterson | Paterson Public School District | 18% | 17% | Meets Expectations | 694 |
| #312 | D- | Trenton Central High School 9th Grade Academy | Trenton | Trenton Public School District | 18% | 29% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 796 |
| #313 | D- | Chartertech High School For The Performing Arts (Charter) | Somers Point | Chartertech High School for the Performing Arts | 17% | 32% | Underperforms Expectations | 370 |
| #314 | D- | Creative Arts High School | Camden | Camden City School District | 17% | 15% | Exceeds Expectations | 202 |
| #315 | D- | William L Dickinson High School | Jersey City | Jersey City Public Schools | 17% | 25% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 2,024 |
| #316 | D- | Burlington City High School | Burlington | Burlington City Public School District | 16% | 24% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 813 |
| #317 | D- | James J Ferris High School | Jersey City | Jersey City Public Schools | 16% | 42% | Underperforms Expectations | 1,348 |
| #318 | D- | Cumberland Regional High School | Bridgeton | Cumberland Regional School District | 15% | 18% | Meets Expectations | 1,124 |
| #319 | D- | Keyport High School | Keyport | Keyport School District | 15% | 24% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 378 |
| #320 | D- | Newark Vocational High School | Newark | Newark Public School District | 15% | 22% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 583 |
| #321 | D- | Paterson Steam High School | Paterson | Paterson Public School District | 15% | 18% | Meets Expectations | 295 |
| #322 | D- | Pleasantville High School | Pleasantville | Pleasantville Public School District | 15% | 18% | Meets Expectations | 924 |
| #323 | D- | The Barack Obama Green Charter High School (Charter) | Plainfield | The Barack Obama Green Charter High School District | 15% | 36% | Underperforms Expectations | 257 |
| #324 | D- | University High School | Newark | Newark Public School District | 15% | 28% | Underperforms Expectations | 426 |
| #325 | D- | Willingboro High School | Willingboro | Willingboro Public School District | 15% | 23% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 842 |
| #326 | D- | East Orange Campus High School | East Orange | East Orange School District | 14% | 17% | Meets Expectations | 1,748 |
| #327 | D- | East Side High School | Newark | Newark Public School District | 14% | 31% | Underperforms Expectations | 2,255 |
| #328 | D- | Harrison High School | Harrison | Harrison Public Schools | 14% | 19% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 716 |
| #329 | D- | J Christian Bollwage Finance Academy | Elizabeth | Elizabeth Public Schools | 14% | 40% | Underperforms Expectations | 342 |
| #330 | D- | Keansburg High School | Keansburg | Keansburg School District | 14% | 32% | Underperforms Expectations | 388 |
| #331 | D- | New Brunswick High School | New Brunswick | New Brunswick School District | 14% | 20% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 2,477 |
| #332 | D- | Abraham Clark High School | Roselle | Roselle Public School District | 13% | 19% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 884 |
| #333 | D- | Academy For Urban Leadership Charter School (Charter) | Perth Amboy | Academy for Urban Leadership Charter School | 13% | 33% | Underperforms Expectations | 376 |
| #334 | D- | Admiral William F Halsey JR Health And Public Safety Academy | Elizabeth | Elizabeth Public Schools | 13% | 23% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 1,299 |
| #335 | D- | Bound Brook High School | Bound Brook | Bound Brook School District | 13% | 17% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 677 |
| #336 | D- | Bridgeton High School | Bridgeton | Bridgeton City School District | 13% | 19% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 1,681 |
| #337 | D- | Camden Big Picture Learning Academy | Camden | Camden City School District | 13% | 18% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 169 |
| #338 | D- | Henry Snyder High School | Jersey City | Jersey City Public Schools | 13% | 27% | Underperforms Expectations | 849 |
| #339 | D- | Lindenwold High School | Lindenwold | Lindenwold Public School District | 13% | 17% | Meets Expectations | 727 |
| #340 | D- | Penns Grove High School | Carneys Point | Penns Grove-Carneys Point Regional School District | 13% | 23% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 576 |
| #341 | D- | Trenton Stem To Civics Charter School (Charter) | Ewing | Trenton Stem-to-Civics Charter School | 13% | 26% | Underperforms Expectations | 585 |
| #342 | D- | Eagle Academy For Young Men Of Newark | Newark | Newark Public School District | 12% | 24% | Underperforms Expectations | 140 |
| #343 | D- | Irvington High School | Irvington | Irvington Public School District | 12% | 16% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 1,684 |
| #344 | D- | Paulsboro High School | Paulsboro | Paulsboro School District | 12% | 18% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 384 |
| #345 | D- | Weequahic High School | Newark | Newark Public School District | 12% | 25% | Underperforms Expectations | 454 |
| #346 | D- | Asbury Park High School | Asbury Park | Asbury Park School District | 11% | 18% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 607 |
| #347 | D- | Camden Prep Inc (K-12) | Camden | Camden Prep Inc. | 11% | 27% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 1,162 |
| #348 | D- | John E Dwyer Technology Academy | Elizabeth | Elizabeth Public Schools | 11% | 28% | Underperforms Expectations | 1,443 |
| #349 | D- | Kipp Cooper Norcross A New Jersey Nonprofit Corporation (K-12) | Camden | KIPP: Cooper Norcross A New Jersey Nonprofit Corporation | 10% | 23% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 2,026 |
| #350 | D- | Mastery Schools Of Camden Inc (K-12) | Camden | Mastery Schools of Camden Inc. | 10% | 22% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 2,880 |
| #351 | F | Dr Charles E Brimm Medical Arts High School | Camden | Camden City School District | 11% | 14% | Meets Expectations | 194 |
| #352 | F | Lincoln High School | Jersey City | Jersey City Public Schools | 11% | 32% | Underperforms Expectations | 942 |
| #353 | F | Passaic High School No 12 | Passaic | Passaic City School District | 11% | 16% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 2,596 |
| #354 | F | Riverside High School | Riverside | Riverside Township School District | 11% | 18% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 479 |
| #355 | F | Thomas A Edison Career And Technical Academy | Elizabeth | Elizabeth Public Schools | 11% | 21% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 810 |
| #356 | F | Academy Charter High School (Charter) | Lake Como | Academy Charter High School | 10% | 39% | Underperforms Expectations | 180 |
| #357 | F | Malcolm X Shabazz High School | Newark | Newark Public School District | 10% | 23% | Underperforms Expectations | 272 |
| #358 | F | West Side High School | Newark | Newark Public School District | 10% | 23% | Underperforms Expectations | 609 |
| #359 | F | Orange High School | Orange | ORANGE BOARD OF EDUCATION School District | 9% | 14% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 1,265 |
| #360 | F | Central High School | Newark | Newark Public School District | 8% | 21% | Underperforms Expectations | 894 |
| #361 | F | John F Kennedy High School | Paterson | Paterson Public School District | 7% | 14% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 2,053 |
| #362 | F | Barringer High School | Newark | Newark Public School District | 6% | 25% | Underperforms Expectations | 1,734 |
| #363 | F | Trenton Central High School Main Campus (K-12) | Trenton | Trenton Public School District | 5% | 17% | Underperforms Expectations | 2,255 |
| #364 | F | Camden High School | Camden | Camden City School District | 4% | 15% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 421 |
| #365 | F | East Side High School | Camden | Camden City School District | 4% | 21% | Underperforms Expectations | 514 |
| #366 | F | Daylighttwilight High School | Trenton | Trenton Public School District | 3% | 31% | Underperforms Expectations | 479 |