| #501 | C- | Sandy Creek Middle School | Sandy Creek | Sandy Creek Central School District | 46% | 61% | Underperforms Expectations | 186 |
| #502 | C- | St Lawrence Middle School | Brasher Falls | Brasher Falls Central School District | 46% | 60% | Underperforms Expectations | 311 |
| #503 | C- | Village Academy | Far Rockaway | | 46% | 17% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 302 |
| #504 | C- | Williamson Middle School | Williamson | Williamson Central School District | 46% | 54% | Underperforms Expectations | 279 |
| #505 | D+ | Stephen And Harriet Myers Middle School | Albany | Albany City School District | 48% | 35% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 641 |
| #506 | D+ | Anne M Dorner Middle School | Ossining | Ossining Union Free School District | 46% | 50% | Underperforms Expectations | 1,033 |
| #507 | D+ | Fieldstone Middle School | Thiells | Haverstraw-Stony Point Csd (north Rockland) | 46% | 52% | Underperforms Expectations | 1,247 |
| #508 | D+ | North Tonawanda Middle School | North Tonawanda | North Tonawanda City School District | 46% | 57% | Underperforms Expectations | 447 |
| #509 | D+ | Saranac Middle School | Saranac | Saranac Central School District | 46% | 58% | Underperforms Expectations | 371 |
| #510 | D+ | Westbury Middle School | Westbury | Westbury Union Free School District | 46% | 40% | Meets Expectations | 1,053 |
| #511 | D+ | Central Park Middle School | Schenectady | Schenectady City School District | 45% | 28% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 658 |
| #512 | D+ | Is 232 | Bronx | | 45% | 16% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 297 |
| #513 | D+ | Lagrange Middle School | Lagrangeville | Arlington Central School District | 45% | 57% | Underperforms Expectations | 865 |
| #514 | D+ | Ms 129 Academy For Independent Learning And Leadership | Bronx | | 45% | 17% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 298 |
| #515 | D+ | Ms 297 | New York | | 45% | 35% | Meets Expectations | 422 |
| #516 | D+ | New School For Leadership And Journalism (the) | Bronx | | 45% | 31% | Exceeds Expectations | 623 |
| #517 | D+ | South Middle School | Brentwood | Brentwood Union Free School District | 45% | 37% | Meets Expectations | 1,033 |
| #518 | D+ | Clyde Savannah Junior High School | Clyde | Clyde-Savannah Central School District | 44% | 49% | Underperforms Expectations | 188 |
| #519 | D+ | Collaborative Arts Middle School | Springfield Gardens | | 44% | 26% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 348 |
| #520 | D+ | College Point Collaborative | College Point | | 44% | 29% | Exceeds Expectations | 452 |
| #521 | D+ | Collegiate Academy Math Personal Awa (Charter) | Brooklyn | Collegiate Academy-Math-Personal Awa | 44% | 18% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 108 |
| #522 | D+ | Cuba Rushford Middle School | Cuba | Cuba-Rushford Central School District | 44% | 58% | Underperforms Expectations | 167 |
| #523 | D+ | East Middle School | Brentwood | Brentwood Union Free School District | 44% | 42% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 1,159 |
| #524 | D+ | Geneva Middle School | Geneva | Geneva City School District | 44% | 45% | Underperforms Expectations | 452 |
| #525 | D+ | Highland Park Community School | Brooklyn | | 44% | 30% | Exceeds Expectations | 277 |
| #526 | D+ | Is 285 Meyer Levin (Magnet) | Brooklyn | | 44% | 25% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 552 |
| #527 | D+ | Is 381 | Brooklyn | | 44% | 28% | Exceeds Expectations | 291 |
| #528 | D+ | Jhs 14 Shell Bank | Brooklyn | | 44% | 38% | Meets Expectations | 452 |
| #529 | D+ | John F Kennedy Middle School | Cheektowaga | Cheektowaga-Sloan Union Free School District | 44% | 58% | Underperforms Expectations | 279 |
| #530 | D+ | Ms 266 Park Place Community Middle School | Brooklyn | | 44% | 28% | Exceeds Expectations | 69 |
| #531 | D+ | Ms 302 Luisa Dessus Cruz (Magnet) | Bronx | | 44% | 19% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 360 |
| #532 | D+ | Pomona Middle School | Suffern | East Ramapo Central School District (spring Valley) | 44% | 32% | Exceeds Expectations | 574 |
| #533 | D+ | Port Chester Middle School | Port Chester | Port Chester-Rye Union Free School District | 44% | 44% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 971 |
| #534 | D+ | Schalmont Middle School | Schenectady | Schalmont Central School District | 44% | 62% | Underperforms Expectations | 561 |
| #535 | D+ | Science And Medicine Middle School (the) | Brooklyn | | 44% | 26% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 282 |
| #536 | D+ | Silas Wood 6th Grade Center | Huntington Station | South Huntington Union Free School District | 44% | 53% | Underperforms Expectations | 399 |
| #537 | D+ | Cheektowaga Middle School | Cheektowaga | Cheektowaga Central School District | 43% | 41% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 627 |
| #538 | D+ | Depew Middle School | Depew | Depew Union Free School District | 43% | 50% | Underperforms Expectations | 427 |
| #539 | D+ | Expeditionary Learning Middle School | Syracuse | Syracuse City School District | 43% | 35% | Meets Expectations | 170 |
| #540 | D+ | John F Kennedy Middle School (Magnet) | Utica | Utica City School District | 43% | 55% | Underperforms Expectations | 695 |
| #541 | D+ | New Pathways Academy | Bronx | | 43% | 16% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 181 |
| #542 | D+ | Carl I Bergerson Middle School | Albion | Albion Central School District | 42% | 49% | Underperforms Expectations | 403 |
| #543 | D+ | Case Middle School | Watertown | Watertown City School District | 42% | 47% | Underperforms Expectations | 626 |
| #544 | D+ | Edmund W Miles Middle School | Amityville | Amityville Union Free School District | 42% | 30% | Meets Expectations | 599 |
| #545 | D+ | Is 211 John Wilson | Brooklyn | | 42% | 25% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 190 |
| #546 | D+ | Is 303 Leadership & Community Service | Bronx | | 42% | 27% | Exceeds Expectations | 332 |
| #547 | D+ | Jhs 144 Michelangelo | Bronx | | 42% | 27% | Exceeds Expectations | 421 |
| #548 | D+ | Jhs 292 Margaret S Douglas | Brooklyn | | 42% | 27% | Exceeds Expectations | 351 |
| #549 | D+ | Middle School Of Media Law And Fine Arts (the) | Brooklyn | | 42% | 20% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 180 |
| #550 | D+ | Mount Markham Middle School | West Winfield | Mount Markham Central School District | 42% | 62% | Underperforms Expectations | 304 |
| #551 | D+ | North Middle School | Brentwood | Brentwood Union Free School District | 42% | 43% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 1,131 |
| #552 | D+ | Sidney Middle School | Sidney | Sidney Central School District | 42% | 59% | Underperforms Expectations | 171 |
| #553 | D+ | Solvay Middle School | Syracuse | Solvay Union Free School District | 42% | 47% | Underperforms Expectations | 438 |
| #554 | D+ | Sunset Park Prep | Brooklyn | | 42% | 32% | Meets Expectations | 440 |
| #555 | D+ | University Prep Charter Middle School (Charter) | Bronx | University Prep Charter Middle School | 42% | 14% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 398 |
| #556 | D+ | Bronx School Of Young Leaders (the) | Bronx | | 41% | 18% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 359 |
| #557 | D+ | Cortland Junior High School | Cortland | Cortland City School District | 41% | 51% | Underperforms Expectations | 299 |
| #558 | D+ | Gowanda Middle School | Gowanda | Gowanda Central School District | 41% | 60% | Underperforms Expectations | 323 |
| #559 | D+ | Ms 247 Dual Language Middle School | New York | | 41% | 37% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 199 |
| #560 | D | Esmt-is 190 | Bronx | | 41% | 18% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 225 |
| #561 | D | Is 192 Linden (the) | Saint Albans | | 41% | 26% | Exceeds Expectations | 335 |
| #562 | D | Knowledge And Power Preparatory Academy Iii | Bronx | | 41% | 19% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 284 |
| #563 | D | Lyndon H Strough Middle School | Rome | Rome City School District | 41% | 46% | Underperforms Expectations | 829 |
| #564 | D | Parkside Preparatory Academy | Brooklyn | | 41% | 24% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 311 |
| #565 | D | Academy Of Applied Mathematics And Technology | Bronx | | 40% | 23% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 303 |
| #566 | D | Bronx Writing Academy | Bronx | | 40% | 17% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 237 |
| #567 | D | Brooklyn Environmental Exploration School (bees) | Brooklyn | | 40% | 20% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 165 |
| #568 | D | Cattaraugus Little Valley Middle School | Cattaraugus | Cattaraugus-Little Valley Central School District | 40% | 61% | Underperforms Expectations | 255 |
| #569 | D | Edmund W Gordon Brooklyn Laboratory Charter School (Charter) | Brooklyn | Edmund W Gordon Brooklyn Laboratory Charter School | 40% | 23% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 269 |
| #570 | D | Elijah Stroud Middle School | Brooklyn | | 40% | 22% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 121 |
| #571 | D | Emolior Academy | Bronx | | 40% | 28% | Exceeds Expectations | 373 |
| #572 | D | Hamilton Grange Middle School | New York | | 40% | 24% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 311 |
| #573 | D | Hoosick Falls Middle School | Hoosick Falls | | 40% | 51% | Underperforms Expectations | 325 |
| #574 | D | Is 61 Leonardo Da Vinci | Corona | | 40% | 40% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 2,079 |
| #575 | D | Is 93 Ridgewood | Ridgewood | | 40% | 34% | Meets Expectations | 985 |
| #576 | D | Jhs 131 Albert Einstein | Bronx | | 40% | 22% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 351 |
| #577 | D | Jhs 162 Willoughby (the) | Brooklyn | | 40% | 42% | Underperforms Expectations | 284 |
| #578 | D | Kappa | Bronx | | 40% | 25% | Exceeds Expectations | 241 |
| #579 | D | Middletown Twin Towers Middle School | Middletown | Middletown City School District | 40% | 33% | Meets Expectations | 858 |
| #580 | D | Monhagen Middle School | Middletown | Middletown City School District | 40% | 29% | Meets Expectations | 817 |
| #581 | D | Mott Hall Community School | Bronx | | 40% | 25% | Exceeds Expectations | 301 |
| #582 | D | Ms 319 Marie Teresa | New York | | 40% | 25% | Exceeds Expectations | 236 |
| #583 | D | Baychester Middle School | Bronx | | 39% | 21% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 267 |
| #584 | D | Dalton Nunda Intermediate School | Nunda | Dalton-Nunda Central School District (keshequa) | 39% | 62% | Underperforms Expectations | 111 |
| #585 | D | East Middle School | Binghamton | Binghamton City School District | 39% | 40% | Underperforms Expectations | 463 |
| #586 | D | Is 250 Robert F Kennedy Community Middle School (the) (Magnet) | Flushing | | 39% | 28% | Meets Expectations | 271 |
| #587 | D | Joseph F Quinn Intermediate School 77 | Ridgewood | | 39% | 28% | Meets Expectations | 627 |
| #588 | D | Knickerbacker Middle School | Troy | Lansingburgh Central School District | 39% | 49% | Underperforms Expectations | 471 |
| #589 | D | Liberty Avenue Middle School | Brooklyn | | 39% | 25% | Exceeds Expectations | 439 |
| #590 | D | Newfield Middle School | Newfield | Newfield Central School District | 39% | 54% | Underperforms Expectations | 157 |
| #591 | D | Oxford Academy Middle School | Oxford | Oxford Academy And Central School District | 39% | 54% | Underperforms Expectations | 234 |
| #592 | D | Pelham Academy Of Academics And Community Engagement | Bronx | | 39% | 25% | Exceeds Expectations | 283 |
| #593 | D | Senator James H Donovan Middle School (Magnet) | Utica | Utica City School District | 39% | 44% | Underperforms Expectations | 730 |
| #594 | D | Urban Assembly Unison School (the) | Brooklyn | | 39% | 23% | Exceeds Expectations | 173 |
| #595 | D | West Middle School | Bay Shore | Brentwood Union Free School District | 39% | 40% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 848 |
| #596 | D | Catherine & Count Basie Middle School 72 | Jamaica | | 38% | 26% | Exceeds Expectations | 270 |
| #597 | D | Creston Academy (Magnet) | Bronx | | 38% | 19% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 432 |
| #598 | D | Highbridge Green School (the) | Bronx | | 38% | 15% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 377 |
| #599 | D | Is 49 Berta A Dreyfus | Staten Island | | 38% | 23% | Exceeds Expectations | 501 |
| #600 | D | Jhs 217 Robert A Van Wyck (Magnet) | Jamaica | | 38% | 43% | Underperforms Expectations | 1,348 |
| #601 | D | Mexico Middle School | Mexico | Mexico Central School District | 38% | 65% | Underperforms Expectations | 614 |
| #602 | D | One World Middle School At Edenwald | Bronx | | 38% | 25% | Exceeds Expectations | 322 |
| #603 | D | Soundview Academy For Culture And Scholarship | Bronx | | 38% | 22% | Exceeds Expectations | 298 |
| #604 | D | Waterloo Middle School | Waterloo | Waterloo Central School District | 38% | 62% | Underperforms Expectations | 338 |
| #605 | D | Bellport Middle School | Bellport | South Country Central School District | 37% | 47% | Underperforms Expectations | 838 |
| #606 | D | Bronx Green Middle School | Bronx | | 37% | 25% | Exceeds Expectations | 341 |
| #607 | D | Is 171 Abraham Lincoln | Brooklyn | | 37% | 24% | Exceeds Expectations | 264 |
| #608 | D | Is 528 Bea Fuller Rodgers School | New York | | 37% | 18% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 249 |
| #609 | D | Kappa V (knowledge And Power Prep Academy) | Brooklyn | | 37% | 22% | Exceeds Expectations | 83 |
| #610 | D | Ms 390 | Bronx | | 37% | 16% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 394 |
| #611 | D | Ms 61 Dr Gladstone H Atwell | Brooklyn | | 37% | 20% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 361 |
| #612 | D | New Heights Middle School | Brooklyn | | 37% | 23% | Exceeds Expectations | 248 |
| #613 | D | Richmond Preparatory Charter School (Charter) | Staten Island | Richmond Preparatory Charter School | 37% | 36% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 219 |
| #614 | D | Isaac Newton Middle School For Math And Science | New York | | 36% | 36% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 312 |
| #615 | D | Robert J Kaiser Middle School | Monticello | Monticello Central School District | 36% | 48% | Underperforms Expectations | 595 |
| #616 | D- | Emerson School (the) | Jamaica | | 36% | 31% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 293 |
| #617 | D- | Ernie Davis Academy | Elmira | Elmira City School District | 36% | 56% | Underperforms Expectations | 802 |
| #618 | D- | Evergreen Middle School For Urban Exploration | Brooklyn | | 36% | 34% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 342 |
| #619 | D- | Is 340 | Brooklyn | | 36% | 31% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 150 |
| #620 | D- | Jhs 80 Mosholu Parkway (the) | Bronx | | 36% | 22% | Exceeds Expectations | 588 |
| #621 | D- | Ms 935 | Brooklyn | | 36% | 24% | Meets Expectations | 181 |
| #622 | D- | North Bronx School Of Empowerment | Bronx | | 36% | 21% | Exceeds Expectations | 370 |
| #623 | D- | Peekskill Middle School | Peekskill | Peekskill City School District | 36% | 47% | Underperforms Expectations | 794 |
| #624 | D- | Pelham Gardens Middle School | Bronx | | 36% | 38% | Underperforms Expectations | 291 |
| #625 | D- | Van Siclen Community Middle School | Brooklyn | | 36% | 21% | Exceeds Expectations | 221 |
| #626 | D- | Andries Hudde (Magnet) | Brooklyn | | 35% | 27% | Meets Expectations | 423 |
| #627 | D- | Community Action School-ms 258 | New York | | 35% | 21% | Exceeds Expectations | 122 |
| #628 | D- | Is 68 Isaac Bildersee | Brooklyn | | 35% | 30% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 214 |
| #629 | D- | Jhs 226 Virgil I Grisson | South Ozone Park | | 35% | 32% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 789 |
| #630 | D- | Kenney Middle School | Hannibal | Hannibal Central School District | 35% | 60% | Underperforms Expectations | 346 |
| #631 | D- | Middle School For Art And Philosphy | Brooklyn | | 35% | 22% | Exceeds Expectations | 146 |
| #632 | D- | Ms 180 Dr Daniel Hale Williams | Bronx | | 35% | 26% | Meets Expectations | 774 |
| #633 | D- | School Of The Future Brooklyn | Brooklyn | | 35% | 20% | Exceeds Expectations | 105 |
| #634 | D- | Frederick Douglass Academy Viii Middle School | Brooklyn | | 34% | 25% | Meets Expectations | 195 |
| #635 | D- | Is 61 William A Morris (Magnet) | Staten Island | | 34% | 33% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 932 |
| #636 | D- | Johnson City Middle School | Johnson City | Johnson City Central School District | 34% | 45% | Underperforms Expectations | 500 |
| #637 | D- | Mott Hall Iv | Brooklyn | | 34% | 22% | Exceeds Expectations | 128 |
| #638 | D- | New Millennium Bronx Academy Of The Arts | Bronx | | 34% | 16% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 163 |
| #639 | D- | Queens United Middle School | Springfield Gardens | | 34% | 25% | Meets Expectations | 191 |
| #640 | D- | Ralph Reed School | Central Islip | Central Islip Union Free School District | 34% | 38% | Underperforms Expectations | 1,149 |
| #641 | D- | Roxboro Road Middle School | Syracuse | North Syracuse Central School District | 34% | 54% | Underperforms Expectations | 715 |
| #642 | D- | South Bronx International Middle School | Bronx | | 34% | 16% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 156 |
| #643 | D- | St Hope Leadership Academy Charter School (Charter) | New York | St. Hope Leadership Academy Charter School | 34% | 17% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 227 |
| #644 | D- | Academy For New Americans | Astoria | | 33% | 28% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 116 |
| #645 | D- | Academy For Personal Leadership And Excellence | Bronx | | 33% | 18% | Exceeds Expectations | 706 |
| #646 | D- | Angelo Patri Middle School (the) | Bronx | | 33% | 17% | Exceeds Expectations | 338 |
| #647 | D- | Liberty Middle School | Liberty | Liberty Central School District | 33% | 34% | Underperforms Expectations | 529 |
| #648 | D- | Malone Middle School | Malone | Malone Central School District | 33% | 52% | Underperforms Expectations | 500 |
| #649 | D- | Middle School 322 | New York | | 33% | 15% | Greatly Exceeds Expectations | 245 |
| #650 | D- | Ms 246 Walt Whitman | Brooklyn | | 33% | 24% | Meets Expectations | 308 |
| #651 | D- | Newark Middle School | Newark | Newark Central School District | 33% | 58% | Underperforms Expectations | 445 |
| #652 | D- | Roosevelt Middle School | Roosevelt | Roosevelt Union Free School District | 33% | 28% | Meets Expectations | 455 |
| #653 | D- | School Of Performing Arts | Bronx | | 33% | 20% | Exceeds Expectations | 196 |
| #654 | D- | South Bronx Academy For Applied Media | Bronx | | 33% | 20% | Exceeds Expectations | 225 |
| #655 | D- | Thomas C Giordano Middle School 45 | Bronx | | 33% | 19% | Exceeds Expectations | 472 |
| #656 | D- | Ausable Valley Middle School | Clintonville | Ausable Valley Central School District | 32% | 62% | Underperforms Expectations | 193 |
| #657 | D- | Fannie Lou Hamer Middle School | Bronx | | 32% | 19% | Exceeds Expectations | 227 |
| #658 | D- | Is 136 Charles O Dewey | Brooklyn | | 32% | 31% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 535 |
| #659 | D- | Jhs 123 James M Kiernan (Magnet) | Bronx | | 32% | 21% | Meets Expectations | 530 |
| #660 | D- | Milton L Olive Middle School | Wyandanch | Wyandanch Union Free School District | 32% | 29% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 581 |
| #661 | D- | South Bronx Early College Academy Charter School (Charter) | Bronx | South Bronx Early College Academy Charter School | 32% | 25% | Meets Expectations | 304 |
| #662 | D- | Thomas Jefferson Middle School | Jamestown | Jamestown City School District | 32% | 51% | Underperforms Expectations | 406 |
| #663 | D- | Wilbur H Lynch Literacy Academy | Amsterdam | Amsterdam City School District | 32% | 52% | Underperforms Expectations | 817 |
| #664 | D- | Is 349 Math Science And Technology (Magnet) | Brooklyn | | 31% | 23% | Meets Expectations | 246 |
| #665 | D- | Leaders Of Tomorrow | Bronx | | 31% | 32% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 387 |
| #666 | D- | Ms 53 Brian Piccolo | Far Rockaway | | 31% | 20% | Exceeds Expectations | 206 |
| #667 | D- | Ps 419 | Flushing | | 31% | 30% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 188 |
| #668 | D- | Renaissance School Of The Arts | New York | | 31% | 19% | Exceeds Expectations | 151 |
| #669 | D- | Restoration Academy (Magnet) | Brooklyn | | 31% | 23% | Meets Expectations | 94 |
| #670 | F | Community Math And Science Prep | New York | | 31% | 16% | Exceeds Expectations | 133 |
| #671 | F | Corona Arts And Sciences Academy | Corona | | 31% | 29% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 740 |
| #672 | F | Is 206 Ann Mersereau | Bronx | | 31% | 15% | Exceeds Expectations | 177 |
| #673 | F | Jhs 22 Jordan L Mott | Bronx | | 31% | 18% | Exceeds Expectations | 264 |
| #674 | F | West Prep Academy (Magnet) | New York | | 31% | 37% | Underperforms Expectations | 168 |
| #675 | F | Accion Academy | Bronx | | 30% | 21% | Meets Expectations | 230 |
| #676 | F | Hudson Junior High School | Hudson | Hudson City School District | 30% | 44% | Underperforms Expectations | 384 |
| #677 | F | Is 584 | Bronx | | 30% | 16% | Exceeds Expectations | 172 |
| #678 | F | M Clifford Miller Middle School | Lake Katrine | Kingston City School District | 30% | 47% | Underperforms Expectations | 822 |
| #679 | F | Cornerstone Academy For Social Action Middle School (casa) | Bronx | | 29% | 25% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 167 |
| #680 | F | Frederick Douglass Academy V Middle School | Bronx | | 29% | 13% | Exceeds Expectations | 239 |
| #681 | F | Grant Middle School | Syracuse | Syracuse City School District | 29% | 19% | Meets Expectations | 608 |
| #682 | F | Is 347 School Of Humanities (Magnet) | Brooklyn | | 29% | 22% | Meets Expectations | 244 |
| #683 | F | Oneida Middle School | Schenectady | Schenectady City School District | 29% | 39% | Underperforms Expectations | 616 |
| #684 | F | Walton Middle School | Walton | Walton Central School District | 29% | 57% | Underperforms Expectations | 189 |
| #685 | F | Young Women's Leadership Of Staten Island | Staten Island | | 29% | 22% | Meets Expectations | 63 |
| #686 | F | Alverta B Gray Schultz Middle School | Hempstead | Hempstead Union Free School District | 28% | 28% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 938 |
| #687 | F | Bronx Mathematics Preparatory School (the) | Bronx | | 28% | 24% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 169 |
| #688 | F | Is 254 | Bronx | | 28% | 21% | Meets Expectations | 469 |
| #689 | F | Jhs 143 Eleanor Roosevelt | New York | | 28% | 32% | Underperforms Expectations | 193 |
| #690 | F | University Neighborhood Middle School | New York | | 28% | 22% | Meets Expectations | 160 |
| #691 | F | Urban Assembly Academy For Future Leaders | New York | | 28% | 20% | Meets Expectations | 73 |
| #692 | F | Is 117 Joseph H Wade | Bronx | | 27% | 16% | Meets Expectations | 358 |
| #693 | F | Jhs 218 James P Sinnott (Magnet) | Brooklyn | | 27% | 25% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 305 |
| #694 | F | Legacy School Of The Arts | Brooklyn | | 27% | 26% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 147 |
| #695 | F | Gloversville Middle School | Gloversville | Gloversville City School District | 26% | 52% | Underperforms Expectations | 548 |
| #696 | F | Is 318 Math Science & Technology Through Arts | Bronx | | 26% | 18% | Meets Expectations | 303 |
| #697 | F | Ps/is 224 | Bronx | | 26% | 19% | Meets Expectations | 198 |
| #698 | F | Bronx Alliance Middle School | Bronx | | 25% | 31% | Underperforms Expectations | 214 |
| #699 | F | George Washington Middle School | Jamestown | Jamestown City School District | 25% | 33% | Underperforms Expectations | 469 |
| #700 | F | Is 229 Roland Patterson | Bronx | | 25% | 19% | Meets Expectations | 166 |
| #701 | F | Ms 113 Ronald Edmonds Learning Center | Brooklyn | | 25% | 26% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 226 |
| #702 | F | East New York Middle School Of Excellence | Brooklyn | | 24% | 21% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 239 |
| #703 | F | Lackawanna Middle School | Lackawanna | Lackawanna City School District | 24% | 48% | Underperforms Expectations | 407 |
| #704 | F | Riverdale Avenue Middle School | Brooklyn | | 24% | 17% | Meets Expectations | 118 |
| #705 | F | Academy Of Health Sciences Charter School (Charter) | Rochester | Academy of Health Sciences Charter School | 23% | 16% | Meets Expectations | 311 |
| #706 | F | Jhs 291 Roland Hayes | Brooklyn | | 23% | 24% | Underperforms Expectations | 267 |
| #707 | F | Chestnut Ridge Middle School | Chestnut Ridge | East Ramapo Central School District (spring Valley) | 22% | 35% | Underperforms Expectations | 646 |
| #708 | F | Poughkeepsie Middle School | Poughkeepsie | Poughkeepsie City School District | 22% | 22% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 877 |
| #709 | F | Whitelaw Reid Academy Of Arts And Business | Brooklyn | | 22% | 21% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 100 |
| #710 | F | Harold O Levy School | New York | | 21% | 24% | Underperforms Expectations | 143 |
| #711 | F | East Lower School | Rochester | Rochester City School District | 20% | 27% | Underperforms Expectations | 304 |
| #712 | F | Lincoln Middle School | Syracuse | Syracuse City School District | 20% | 25% | Underperforms Expectations | 508 |
| #713 | F | Mott Hall Bridges Academy | Brooklyn | | 19% | 17% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 175 |
| #714 | F | Ms 301 Paul L Dunbar | Bronx | | 17% | 17% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 182 |
| #715 | F | New Design Middle School | New York | | 17% | 21% | Underperforms Expectations | 73 |
| #716 | F | Is 313 School Of Leadership Development | Bronx | | 16% | 16% | Doesn't Meet Expectations | 172 |
| #717 | F | Salmon River Middle School | Fort Covington | Salmon River Central School District | 16% | 48% | Underperforms Expectations | 313 |
| #718 | F | Brighton Academy | Syracuse | Syracuse City School District | 15% | 16% | Underperforms Expectations | 342 |
| #719 | F | Clary Middle School | Syracuse | Syracuse City School District | 14% | 19% | Underperforms Expectations | 275 |
| #720 | F | Seed Harlem | New York | | 13% | 23% | Underperforms Expectations | 127 |
| #721 | F | Academy Of Public Relations | Bronx | | 11% | 21% | Underperforms Expectations | 125 |
| #722 | F | Syracuse Stem At Blodgett | Syracuse | Syracuse City School District | 11% | 15% | Underperforms Expectations | 369 |
| #723 | F | Northwest College Preparatory High School | Rochester | Rochester City School District | 7% | 17% | Underperforms Expectations | 252 |